Schultz is no where near Gardiner. Hes had on 50 pts season. W.e. think what you will you wont listen. Team D far exceeds pure positional D.
We are built scoring heavy. D is avg and last yr 12th best goals against so that's top 3rd in the league. And our goalie is a vez candidate all day.
Take shots against, high danger shots into account. Faced 200 more shots than any other goalie..he stole us several in season and 2 in the playoffs.
Whilst Capitals gave up 8 more in the season Holtby stunk until the conference finals then stood on his head. No Holtby Vegas wins the cup no question
The defense is below average. The reason why we were 12th in the league and 2nd in the east in gaa was because Andersen and mcelhinney stood on their heads all season. The leafs did this while giving up the 4th most shots against per game, an average of 32 iirc. It may be more. In the playoffs, their defense got worse, evident by them up 35 shots against per game in the playoffs and allowing 28 goals in 7 games. That an average off 4 goals against per game. Without elite goaltending, allowing 35 shots per game isn't not going to win you a series, let alone a cup.
As for Andersen, he stole us games 3,5 and 6, while preforming less than average in the other games. The defense was brutal in all those games, except for game 4. ironically, Andersen wasn't good in that game.
The capitals gave up 8 more goals in the regular season because holtby sucked in the regular season. However in the playoffs he played amazing. Andersen did the opposite. The caps defense was bad in the first 3/4 of the season, then rhey added kempny and played much better. The leafs haven't added anyone to make that defense better like the caps did with kempny.