Who are these top defenders ? Marta? Dumolin? Those aren't top 4. No reason to think Dermott wont be. He was our best D even in playoffs. Zaitsev had 38pts which is just ok but huge minutes against top lines in his first yr handled well. I think its him we would trade. Gardiner is top 4 53pts plus 9 this yr 51pts plus 22 the yr before.
I dont think you grasp the magnitude of JT taking 2.5 AAV less. When a star does that it trickles down the lineup. 34 16 and 29 will take a little discount each. I think Nylander gets 6 to 6.5, Marner 8 8.5 and Matthew's 10 10.5.
Next yr ufa ..Hainsey, Carrick, Jake..I think we lose the first 2 if to re up Jake. Jake gets 4.4 5.5. The also Johnsson who is going to be a 25 30g scorer next yr is rfa right now I think we are signing him this summer 1million 2 or 3 yrs so all forwards locked up by September IF we sign big 3 this off season which I think we will.
You're the same guy before we got JT arguing with me that because bozak signed in St Louis didnt mean anything...lol
Maataa dumilon letang and Schultz and are all top 4 defenders.
Just because Tavares took a discount doesn't mean the rest of the gang will for sure. Even if they do take a discount, the changes won't be drastic.
Jakes cap hit on his next contract will be in an interval much higher than 4.4 to 5.5. Hes in the range of 5.25 to 6.
Johnson isn't guaranteed to be a 25 to 30 goal scorer. He's getting 3rd line minutes at best which doesn't give him a good chance to hit that mark. If he does hit that mark, then he will want an expensive contract as well, and the leafs don't need that at all.
As for your last paragraph, what are you saying ? Are you saying bozak doesn't make a difference in St. Louis? He does make a difference for them. He gives them a offensive 3C than can produce 40 points.