Stamkos in 2011-12 outproduced 10th in points by 19, and the 20th highest point producer by 26.
He outscored the runner up for the richard by 10 goals, then had a 24 and a 29 goal gap over the 10th and 20th best goal scorers.
All the while being 3rd in PPG.
In comparison, Kucherov currently has a 17 point lead over 10th place, and a 24 point lead over 20th
PPG wise, the gap is 42 points over 20th place, and 28 over 10th.
If he actually maintains his PPG which i'd think many find to be unlikely. It's him no question.
But if the point difference is more in line with his current lead. I'd pick Stamkos.
Also, i dont think anyone can use the linemate argument. Kucherov has 17 points more than Point, while Stamkos had 23 more than Martin St Louis.