Perimeter plays could work if they were set plays and done fast to open lanes. Our guys are slow thinking with the puck, wait to pass until under pressure, or leave Hughes all alone by the blueline. I mentioned in the GDT that the Sedins were able to quarterback the pp from behind the net, its harder for Hughes to do it way out at the point
Fluidity.
That’s what is missing on the PP. everyone is stagnant, and just because your foot speed is slow doesn’t mean you can’t play fast. Famously, Walter would show Wayne as a kid how much faster the puck could leave the zone with a pass and not by skating it out. We as you allude to, are playing a slow game in many ways on the PP.
I have no idea what makes a unit that complacent, if I’m out on a PP I’m thinking “ooh free points if I work”. I don’t get it.
We were incredibly blessed to have the Sedins as long as we did, for the most part in their prime there were almost no set plays - sure they did the drop breakout, but once they cooked they did so with zest. It was truly hockey played at such a high level, like two Kasparovs - move shit around and wait for a look and pounce.
Really that’s how most goals are scored in hockey, off a broken play. And that’s nothing to say of the subtle picks, switching spots, defenseman pinching as forwards, and forwards were always on the ball to cover the point when there was a pinch. I liken hockey to jazz, you have to take what you are given and have willingness to improvise. This PP is more like the Hamster dance in it’s ridiculous, repetitive, annoyance.
Having set plays is fine but our creativity is being stifled with the amount we’ve had. The kids don’t know how to play pond hockey.