Gauthier 5v5 per 60 stats with the Sens (15 games)
Goals 1.28
Points 2.14
Shots 7.27
Giveaways .43
Takeaways 2.99
Hits 13.68
-----
CF% 48.68
Gauthier 5v5 per 60 with the Rangers (40 games)
Goals 1.09
Points 1.63
Shots 6.52
Giveaways 1.45
Takeaways 1.09
Hits 12.67
Joseph 5v5 per 60 (54 games)
Goals 0
Points 1.25
Shots 5.01
Giveaways 1.46
Takeaways 1.88
Hits 7.82
-----------------
CF% 49.45
Gauthier Cost/pt $57,142
Joseph Cost/pt $163,888
==========================================
I could make a case to resign Gauthier to a 1m or less per contract and to dump Joseph.
Gauthier is a 4th liner outproducing a 3m AAV player we have playing on the 3rd line
We get a somewhat less polished player that can skate as well and plays more physical while out producing the other on the score sheet with less opportunity. We give up a more seasoned player who can PK at a decent but replaceable level.
Verdict
Sign Gauthier to play on the 4th line.
Move Joseph try to recoup something and channel the savings into upgrading or other needs