There seems to be 2 contradictory thoughts going on. Here is how I see it. Chevy keeps picking guys off the waiver wire because a farm team is ****. We can't even replace 4th line grinders from within....how bad is that? The only way to start strengthening the organization is developing more depth. Picks eventually = Depth. Teams that were able to make big moves did so because they had prospects other teams wanted that they felt they could part with. The prospects Chevy has that others want (Scheifele, Trouba, Lowry) he can't part with. It seems obvious to me that Chevy is trying to end the cycle of mediocrity rather than perpetuate it. If that is drinking the kool-aid give me another cup because after even 2 years of being an also ran I want more, but I'm willing to wait a little while.
I'm not opposed to standing pat at the trade deadline - things are a bit out of whack (see: Pominville to MN), so in terms of acquiring players it's arguably the right decision. I'm fine with not shipping Hainsey off for a 2nd rounder or whatever he would've commanded.
But Chevy has had nearly 2 years now and his biggest trade deal is Oduya to Chicago for a 2nd + a 3rd round pick. His second biggest is bringing in Fehr for a 4th and a prospect (Paquette?). After that it's all AHL moves (Aliu for Negrin, Esposito for McCardle, etc.).
You can give him credit for trying to address the #1C problem by signing Jokinen. Sure, there were some warning signs that he maybe wasn't the answer: Calgary fans' opinions, and maybe the idea that a slow, 34-year-old who played 82 games with Iginla on Calgary's 1st line and coming off his best season since 08-09 might be due for some regression...but you can argue that even taking all those red flags into account, you couldn't predict how terrible his season has been.
Chevy's been saying for a while that RW is a problem. Was Jussi Jokinen not an upgrade on Mittens? Are you telling me that there were no deals?
I know the rule for Chevy critics around here is to provide concrete solutions, so how does this sound: We trade Byfuglien to Philly for...well, you could probably get just about anything out of them - the Flyer's are always down for a big trade. Voracek or Simmonds ++ (prospect and 2nd round pick). The point is we have assets coveted by other teams - and the core isn't working here, but Chevy's too cautious to make a move (or at least he hasn't made a deal yet). Maybe it's all part of this omniscient plan to only draft talent? That's going to take a lot of luck and time...
Of course moving Buff to RW (which I heard was a crazy idea that would never happen) might fill that hole too.