Fogelhund
Registered User
- Sep 15, 2007
- 21,270
- 23,754
This is by far the least intelligent post in this topic.
Great post. Well thought out. Nice argument. Thanks.
This is by far the least intelligent post in this topic.
No clue what Myers has to do with this but Jets have had a strong history of drafting in the 1st. Roslovic was pick 25 and in the 2018 draft players like Dellandrea, Alexyev, Wise, Hallander, Kaut, Tychonick, Olofsson, Berggren or Lundkvist etc could be available. Would want a better 1st round pick and I think if multiple teams bid on Myers a better pick would be ponied up. As for who is better, it is a bit tough to compare since they are different types of Dmen. If you are looking for an offensive catalyst that is good on the PP and skating with the puck out the zone but has some questionable defensive IQ at times (Myers did lead the Jets in PK TOI, 4th in EV TOI and 2nd in PP TOI) then Myers is your guy. If you want a steady and saffe stay at home defensive dman that has limited offensive upside then Tanev is your guy. Would be an interesting poll.If you trade Myers for 25oa and a b prospect that will never play for the Jets you are crazy. And what makes Myers better than tanev?
Would a 3rd rounder for Goldobin work since everyone has a propsect like him?Definitely not what Leafs fans think. They think he projects and have said on this board many times that he will guaranteed be a 60+ point player. Every other fan base have said otherwise. I believe all teams have players like him and that he isn't something to write home about. We have our own in Goldobin.
My point was that I think tanev is much better and far more valuable to the Canucks (as opposed to Myers value is to the jets) yet you are ready to tell canucks fans that a return of less than you would take for Myers, is fair value. I don't agree. It's not even close.No clue what Myers has to do with this but Jets have had a strong history of drafting in the 1st. Roslovic was pick 25 and in the 2018 draft players like Dellandrea, Alexyev, Wise, Hallander, Kaut, Tychonick, Olofsson, Berggren or Lundkvist etc could be available. Would want a better 1st round pick and I think if multiple teams bid on Myers a better pick would be ponied up. As for who is better, it is a bit tough to compare since they are different types of Dmen. If you are looking for an offensive catalyst that is good on the PP and skating with the puck out the zone but has some questionable defensive IQ at times (Myers did lead the Jets in PK TOI, 4th in EV TOI and 2nd in PP TOI) then Myers is your guy. If you want a steady and saffe stay at home defensive dman that has limited offensive upside then Tanev is your guy. Would be an interesting poll.
KK could be a 40-50 pt top 9 forward or he could tap out to a player like Joel Armia. Having a younger and cheaper Joel Armia is not a bad thing. KK is not the type of prospect that I think the Jets would covet, but it isn't awful.
Not advocating a trade for Myers, Id rather keep him, but if the Jets want to acquire another C either via trade or Free Agency he'd be a guy that might be a cap casualty (there are other guys to consider too)
Myers isn't as valuable to the jets but he is still valued peice league wide. Also i never said the boldedMy point was that I think tanev is much better and far more valuable to the Canucks (as opposed to Myers value is to the jets) yet you are ready to tell canucks fans that a return of less than you would take for Myers, is fair value. I don't agree. It's not even close.
Its stuff like this that just irks most fans, you giving reasons that most don't care about. If you want to bring up his playing on the 4th line, why not bring up Tanevs injury history because he blocks shots with his face?
Wow, I can't even wrap my head around that kind of thought process. You people don't care about context etc.
And it's just disingenuous to compare player usage and player injury history. You can change player usage but if a player is just injury prone, that's not going to change.
Anyway, I'm pretty sure Dubas is keeping Kapanen and in a year we won't be needing to give people reasons anymore.
I can't speak for that poster, but many Leafs fans have offered 1st+2nd+2nd for Tanev....and in the Myers thread, many Jets fans were good with les than that for Myers.My point was that I think tanev is much better and far more valuable to the Canucks (as opposed to Myers value is to the jets) yet you are ready to tell canucks fans that a return of less than you would take for Myers, is fair value. I don't agree. It's not even close.
Haven't seen many offer 1st+2nd+2nd. Vancouver would do that in a heartbeat though.I can't speak for that poster, but many Leafs fans have offered 1st+2nd+2nd for Tanev....and in the Myers thread, many Jets fans were good with les than that for Myers.
I can't speak for that poster, but many Leafs fans have offered 1st+2nd+2nd for Tanev....and in the Myers thread, many Jets fans were good with les than that for Myers.
I have offered it many times, some agree....some don't.Haven't seen many offer 1st+2nd+2nd. Vancouver would do that in a heartbeat though.
Just curious from both a Leafs & Nucks fans pov what do you think KK projects to become at the nhl level?
Leafs fans?
Nucks fans?
Please give me your projection. Thx
I have offered it many times, some agree....some don't.
DRW204 -What is this the?Listen, not a leafs fan. To call AM injury prone is laughable especially in the same realm as Chris Tanev. And there have been plenty of reasonable offers in this thread/forum for an injury prone defensive dman nearing 30
Tanev. Lol
If your a Nucks fan you know our prospect pool is looking better then the majority of NHL teams, draft picks are good, however, it’s not all we needId do it in a heartbeat, we are going to suck until Van realizes they actually need to start accumulating draft picks to build through the draft
Its stuff like this that just irks most fans, you giving reasons that most don't care about. If you want to bring up his playing on the 4th line, why not bring up Tanevs injury history because he blocks shots with his face?
Just curious from both a Leafs & Nucks fans pov what do you think KK projects to become at the nhl level?
Leafs fans?
Nucks fans?
Please give me your projection. Thx
I think you missed my point.Tanev blocks shots with his face? Maybe some1 should teach him how to block a shot ie not with ur face lmao. So he's stupid along with being injury prone haha
That’s hilarious!If you really want him to play for your team, your first step should be to synthesize the stuff that makes Wolverine heal fast. Giving him adamantium bones might work too actually, not sure if the NHL would greenlight it as a performance enhancing drug though/illegal equipment though.
Edit: Can we please limit the Tanev trade proposals to 1 a week. I get nauseous reading every single one.