Hyman vs Gallagher vs Pageau.

[GrandmaCookie]

All 1992 born player. All late round pick (4 for pageau, 5 for Hyman and Gallagher). Similar type of goal scorer, similar stats this season. All three had similar stats last season.

Gallagher has the edge if we compare career (point wise), but I have a feeling that Pageau will win this poll due to his goal being higher than Tyman and Gallagher this season and the hype surrounding him since last year .

Not considering contract, which player do you think his the best player of the three?

This season:

Hyman:

22

7

7

14 (Counting tonight's game)

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Pageau:

22

9

5

14

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Gallagher:

21

7

5

12

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Career
Hyman:

323

77

88

165 (0.51pts/game)

[TFOOT] [/TFOOT]

- Highest season in goal 21
- Highest season in points 41
- 2x 20 goal season


Gallagher:

568

180

166

346(0.61pts/game)

[TFOOT] [/TFOOT]

- Highest season in goal is 33
- Highest season in points is 54
- 4 x20 goal season
- 2x 30 goal season

Pageau:

457

98

100

198(0.43)

[TFOOT] [/TFOOT]

- Highest season in goal is 26
- Highest season in points is 43
- 1 x20 goal season

Click to read more...

 

[Foppberg]

Gally
JGP

Hyman

 

[GrandmaCookie]

Gally
JGP

Hyman

Then why did you vote for Pageau?

 

[hamzarocks]

Hyman AINEC.

I wouldn't trade Hyman for any of those two. Add Tom Wilson, Josh Anderson, whoever else onto the list. Hyman is better than them

He is the best grinder in the league. Can play on any line, and give 50-60 points

 

[TheBeastCoast]

Pageau being a centre pushes him over Hyman but I am slightly torn on that one. Hyman is still awesome though...pls re-sign.

 

[Albus Dumbledore]

Pageau or Hyman hard to decide.

 

[nobody]

JGP and Hyman are on par. Gally is a tier below. Gally used to be better than both, however. Not anymore.

 

[HabsInsider]

Zach Hyman, all day and every day.

He's a priceless treasure. I can't even put it into words.

He needs to be a Leaf for life.

 

[GrandmaCookie]

Hyman AINEC.

I wouldn't trade Hyman for any of those two. Add Tom Wilson, Josh Anderson, whoever else onto the list. Hyman is better than them

He is the best grinder in the league. Can play on any line, and give 50-60 points

Has never scored more than 41 points in the NHL.

AINEC for Hyman is pushing it. Gallagher has outscored him everyseason since he entered the league.

 

[Critical13]

I'll go Hyman but the smart money is probably on Pageau.

 

[Pyrophorus]

If we're talking intangibles, it is Hyman AINEC.

 

[hamzarocks]

Has never scored more than 41 points in the NHL.

AINEC for Hyman is pushing it. Gallagher has outscored him everyseason since he entered the league.

This year and last he has been on pace for 55-60 points and has been at a similar pace as both players along with his incredible defensive game. I can except the AINEC is too much but seeing Hyman mess around with the oilers tonight had me to excited.

Realistically this is pretty close, I still like Hyman due to exposure to his playstyle and having seen him have chemistry with any linemate he plays with. Just an incredibly hard-working guy who has added a lot of skilled plays over the years.

Gallagher this year is having a down year but overall is pretty good. I'll say really slight edge Hyman over JGP and Gallagher. Both though are good players just their contract AAV is hefty, hoping Hyman doesn't come at 5-6 million on his new deal

 

[Nizdizzle]

I'm not voting because I haven't watched a ton of Gallagher and Pageau recently, but Hyman is legitimately a huge part of the Leafs. Every line he is on instantly because incredibly effective. One of the hardest working players in the league.

Amazing thinking back to the days when many people (including myself) criticized him being put on the top line.

 

[Mitch nylander]

Gallagher for me, as a leafs fan. I think he would be the perfect add for our team.

 

[Michael HOMERUNing]

Gally g baby

 

[34]

Hyman for me.

 

[BM14]

Hyman played on a torn ligament in his knee in the playoffs.
Hyman blocked a shot with his face in the playoffs.

I'm not discrediting the other 2 as they are very, very good by Hyman would improve almost any line in the NHL.

 

[Pyrophorus]

I only know JGP from Ottawa, where he shone once in a blue moon

Can Gally play 3rd of 4th line, in a traditional sense? Can he go up and down the lineup?
Is he 203lbs, can get along the boards and scoop out pucks?
Gally would be in the slot, where he is money, Hyman has to get dirty to get goals.

 

[GrandmaCookie]

I only know JGP from Ottawa, where he shone once in a blue moon

Can Gally play 3rd of 4th line, in a traditional sense? Can he go up and down the lineup?
Is he 203lbs, can get along the boards and scoop out pucks?
Gally would be in the slot, where he is money, Hyman has to get dirty to get goals.

Gally has been playing with a 3rd C for at least 2 seasons if that counts. So yes he can have a role anywhere in the top 9.

I'm suprised Pageau isn't getting more love, I though he was pretty hyped.

 

[RealisticLeaf55]

I honestly don't know who to vote for. All three are heart and soul guys.

 

[Erik Alfredsson]

I only know JGP from Ottawa, where he shone once in a blue moon

Can Gally play 3rd of 4th line, in a traditional sense? Can he go up and down the lineup?
Is he 203lbs, can get along the boards and scoop out pucks?
Gally would be in the slot, where he is money, Hyman has to get dirty to get goals.

JGP would have massive games once in a blue moon, but even if he wasn't scoring 4 goals in a game, he was at the very least, an excellent defensive shutdown centreman that could matchup against the Bergeron's and the Crosby's and do a damn good job of keeping them off the scoreboard.

 

[sansabri]

um, the two-time 30 goal scorer

 

[The Beyonder]

Hyman is the epitome of "never takes a shift off".

 

[Brobust]

Then why did you vote for Pageau?

Maybe he can't read.

 

[David Suzuki]

Hyman AINEC.

I wouldn't trade Hyman for any of those two. Add Tom Wilson, Josh Anderson, whoever else onto the list. Hyman is better than them

He is the best grinder in the league. Can play on any line, and give 50-60 points

Right around the time Leafs fans start saying stuff like this they usually lose a stinker so bet against them big time next game to all my degenerates out there.