Lil Sebastian Cossa
Opinions are share are my own personal opinions.
- Jul 6, 2012
- 11,436
- 7,446
I really think what gets glossed over like it's fine wine is and was how bad Ken Holland was with the cap that he was able to use to sign players. Signings were down right terrible imo, and what lead to these prolonged years of being real bad. Frazen over Hossa started it and it basically never got better and he seemed to double down on himself even.
IMO, Someone else dealing out money wouldn't of paid guys like Abdelkader/Helm/Dekeyser/Howard/Nielson/Weiss/Daley among some others and those choices by Holland really lead to the spiral down the tubes type rebuild we've felt. (IMO, again).
IF, some of those players were signed for half the term, half the money, or straight up different players all together... I think things would of shake'n out a lot different, and Red Wings needed someone other than Ken Holland leading/making the choices.
A lot of the trades were even bad/mediocre at best near the end.(The one's when Red Wings were buyers not sellers.)
Frankly, you should keep DDK and Howard out of that listing.
Howard was a really good goalie when he was signed to 6x5.3. Howard's contract looks bad because they misjudged what they had in Mrazek. They handled the two goalies very poorly together. Sign Howard and stick by him (i.e. you don't lose your job because of injury) and you don't have him rushing back from his groin injury from which he never really recovered. Sign Mrazek and deal Howard like you apparently told him you'd do and he gets a consistent workload and you don't have the infighting... or you realize what Mrazek is earlier and move on from him earlier. They did neither of those things and ended up paying Mrazek 4.0M while paying Howard 5.3M.
DDK got a bad rap after injury. He was very good in his first couple years. He then got slotted above his talent level because the Wings didn't have a suitable top pair guy and then he got hurt and lost what meager strength he did have.
The others I'm not gonna fight you on. But Howard was better than people gave him credit for and they jerked him and Mrazek around very poorly in the middle of the 2010s so much that I'm not surprised that both ended up flopping.