Exactly how I feel about Plekanec...solid player, but overrated by most Habs fans.
He's not the two way dynamo most portray him to be. His seasons tend to mirror themselves, strong starts until he reaches a climax then he disapears as the games become more and more important down the stretch.
Though even at his worst, he remains a solid player who won't hurt you...just don't expect him to elevate his game when you need it
Hey, that's what my wife says about me.
Pretty much. It's funny how Pleks never gets the defacto DD defense (or DDDD) of 'Well you just gotta play him with big power wingers!!111!'
Give Pleks some great power wingers and many in this thread eat lots of crow.
There's no doubt that we've done no favours for ourselves with our lack of size. Plecs, Max... tons of guys would play a lot rougher if they had protection. Look at Price this year, NOBODY clearing pucks or helping him out. And nobody (other than little Gallagher) parks themselves in front of the net. It's a dimension we've been missing for a long, long time.
I think about A Kostitsyn and how much better he could've been if he had an elite center and some power forwards to play with. People say he was a bust but really, we did very little to help him succeed.
As for Plecs, yes some big wingers would help. But regardless, he's still a little to soft for my tastes. If he had a little more grit (heart?) he'd be a much, much better player.
A certain amount of size yes is important, but also the ability to play big, and this is something Plekenec has difficulty doing, Look no further than our own team, Gallagher is small but can complete in the hard areas to get goals. Look at Kane from Chicago, conn smyth winner, battled against one of the leagues toughest and biggest defense and still came out on top. so I think we have to start talking less about pure size and more about players who can play big.
Gallagher is a great example. Kane, not so much.
So now Plekanec is a third line center? Third line centers are in the top 20 in points while playing a two-way role with the majority of their starts in the defensive zone?
You know, there's more to hockey than what commentators say on RDS and TSN, right?
And yes, the only comparison with Bergeron is their tactical role. Bergeron is also a top 10, maybe top 5 centre in the league. Do we have to trade Pacioretty too for not being Corey Perry?
Bergeron is not a top five center in this league and probably not top ten. He's a solid two way guy who's being massively overrated. He's not Datsyuk, Toews, Stamkos, Crosby, Tavares, Malkin, Giroux... Yes, he's more complete on D than some of these players but there's no way in hell I'd take him ahead of say... Tavares. Tavares can carry a team by himself in a way that Bergeron can't. And Bergeron has a LOT of support behind him.
Kane makes Plekanec look like a power forward. It's not always about cliches about "playing big", the reason Kane came through in the playoffs is because he's ridiculously skilled.
And because his linemates did all the dirty work. Toews was unbelievable in front of the net and Bickell went right after Chara.