Higher sv% next year, Campbell or 1 of Murray / Samsonov

Campbell vs 1 of Samsonov or Murray

  • Campbell

    Votes: 117 56.5%
  • Sam / Murray

    Votes: 90 43.5%

  • Total voters
    207

Kelly

Registered User
Nov 12, 2012
14,899
7,479
I had one defiant oilers poster tell me how campbell was a great signing before the start of the season. My exact rebuttal was this “your team may or may not do well, but I assure you, if by some define intervention your oilers go to the finals or win the Stanley cup, I guarantee you, it won’t be jack campbell as the starter. So you better hope skinner isn’t the next binnington, that’s your only hope”. He scoffed and said we’ll see. I guess we are seeing….that I was right
last time I checked it's November and the playoffs are like 5 months away.

I mean 20 games in, that's a lot more reasonable take then all the dolts who bumped the Murray thread after 1... :laugh:

But Campbell still has time to turn it around. Clearly proved last season he's a very hot or cold goaltender.
 

PromisedLand

I need more FOOD
Dec 3, 2016
43,073
55,613
Hogwarts
Nice voting there HF :laugh:

1669478895913.png
 

sennysensen

Registered User
Feb 7, 2018
976
1,204
I think Samsonov has the best chance to be good. I don't see him as elite, but potentially a solid #1. Moves well, is quick, needs to refine technique, which can be done.

Campbell: mentally weak, can't take the pressure.

Murray: always injured, if he gets his 4th concussion in 4 years, that could be it. Looks slower than his first couple years, weak glove gets exploited.
 

MCR74

Registered User
Nov 11, 2022
3,056
3,273
Murray---------------6GP----2.51 GA------.921 SA%
Samsonov --------- 8 GP..... 2.23 GA....... .921 SA%
Montembeault------8 GP----2 .48 GA---- .924 SA%
Ya your right never mind.:popcorn:

Leafs - 3rd in conference
Habs - 10th in conference

Never mind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AvroArrow

ole ole

Registered User
Oct 7, 2017
11,937
6,021
Leafs - 3rd in conference
Habs - 10th in conference

Never mind.
And that is because of the Leafs Superior goaltending ...right?
Since your the one that brought up the Habs goaltending.
Again....

Murray---------------6GP----2.51 GA------.921 SA%
Samsonov --------- 8 GP..... 2.23 GA....... .921 SA%
Montembeault------8 GP----2 .48 GA---- .924 SA%
 
  • Haha
Reactions: EquivalentStay

MCR74

Registered User
Nov 11, 2022
3,056
3,273
Murray---------------6GP----2.51 GA------.921 SA%
Samsonov --------- 8 GP..... 2.23 GA....... .921 SA%
Montembeault------8 GP----2 .48 GA---- .924 SA%

Keep posting those stats all you want, I'd rather have Murray and Samsonov. They're getting the job done, while your team sucks.
 

ole ole

Registered User
Oct 7, 2017
11,937
6,021
Keep posting those stats all you want, I'd rather have Murray and Samsonov. They're getting the job done, while your team sucks.
They are playing no better than our goalie. So it all comes down to your team minus the goalie is playing better.
But feel right to disagree with the proof since your the one that brought up the Habs goaltending.
Murray---------------6GP----2.51 GA------.921 SA%
Samsonov --------- 8 GP..... 2.23 GA....... .921 SA%
Montembeault------8 GP----2 .48 GA---- .924 SA%
 

MCR74

Registered User
Nov 11, 2022
3,056
3,273
They are playing no better than our goalie. So it all comes down to your team minus the goalie is playing better.
But feel right to disagree with the proof since your the one that brought up the Habs goaltending.
Murray---------------6GP----2.51 GA------.921 SA%
Samsonov --------- 8 GP..... 2.23 GA....... .921 SA%
Montembeault------8 GP----2 .48 GA---- .924 SA%

So his stats are better than the Leafs, your team sucks either way.

I wouldn't take him on my team for free.
 

ole ole

Registered User
Oct 7, 2017
11,937
6,021
Certainly a take. Come into a thread say you are just glad your team doesn't have any of the goalies and then use Sam Montembeault as your argument. The guy hasn't had a year with a save percentage that hit the 9's ever. So I mean...if you aren't buying the start from Murray or Samsonov but ole Sammy boy is the one eh?
Another Leaf poster brought in the Habs goalie trying to make fun of them.
I just proved that the leafs goaltending hasn't been any better .
He just responds back with nothing that has to do with either goaltenders.
I wouldn't want either of the Leafs goalie in this discussion nor do i care about Montembeaul either.
I wouldn't want any of the 3.
In fact i wouldn't want any of the Habs or Leafs tenders if i had the choice.

So his stats are better than the Leafs, your team sucks either way.

I wouldn't take him on my team for free.
That's your right but try sticking to what the thread is about instead of trying to derail it.
 

abo9

Registered User
Jun 25, 2017
9,094
7,189
So his stats are better than the Leafs, your team sucks either way.

I wouldn't take him on my team for free.

No your team sucks

Montembeault > Murray, Samsonov

All three over .920SV%
What a season
 

ER89

Registered User
Jul 25, 2018
4,576
4,553
I think Samsonov has the best chance to be good. I don't see him as elite, but potentially a solid #1. Moves well, is quick, needs to refine technique, which can be done.

Campbell: mentally weak, can't take the pressure.

Murray: always injured, if he gets his 4th concussion in 4 years, that could be it. Looks slower than his first couple years, weak glove gets exploited.
So this is what sens fans are saying about Murray... Weak glove.... To placate yourself for your dismal season thus far?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MCR74

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad