i think we did a fabulous job... I collected the hockey news future watch for around 30 years and their top 50 rankings... trust me, we are very good compared to most of what they had to say
I do hope one lesson can be learnt here by some of us 'im an experts'
a lot of s%^& will happen between the time guys get drafted and a few years later when you get judged for how you evaluated the kid. we had the benefit of ranking kids after their draft class. we had seem some development of maturity and strength and confidence and coaching. and we still are high on some guys that look like they got no future while completely 'missing' on other guys that now look like top 4 dmen
give the scouts a break... give the drafting gms a break.... EVERYONE will sometimes get it wrong {and by sometimes I mean like more often than they get it right}
at the end of the day though... doing these rankings is supposed to be about having some fun. I think we all had fun. I hope we do it again soon