Hawkaholic
Registered User
Sometimes high picks fail at any position. We have no goalie prospects.
Simpson, Carruth, Namilov, Raanta, and Tompkins look like goalies that were drafted/signed by the Hawks. Maybe I'm mistaken.
Sometimes high picks fail at any position. We have no goalie prospects.
Raanta was a free agent, but the point still applies. Skaters are more of a sure thing and need to be replaced quicker than goalies. With Crawford locked up long term it makes a whole lot more sense to look at goalies in later rounds and pick up skaters early to replace the guys that leave via free agency or trade because of cap restraints.
I am simply stating a fact. And LA has won two cups with a goalie drafted in the 3rd round. The only poor depth we have in a key position is goaltending, which is set for the next 6 years anyway, and you can find good goalies for free without wasting draft picks on them.
Hawks can't be included in a group of the best teams in the league? is that what you are saying? How are the Hawks living anymore dangerously than pretty much every other team in the league? If any team loses their starting goalie, they would be in the same position as us with regard to depth. Not many back ups in the league could win a Cup.
Which ones do you like?
The Hawks use to be Stanley Cup contenders NOW they are Stanley Cup pretenders.
Poor coaching and limited moves by Bowman to fill the holes with overspending get you nothing but close. Close doesn't win Cups.
Name me one KEY addition that Bowman has made that been SIGNIFICANT? No #2 center like forever and the 3rd and 4th lines are not close to what they use to be. Bowman is no Holland and runs the show like a rookie G.M. Probably because that's how much talent he has.
Thanks to Q putting in Asst. coaches who operate just like him. The PP and PK has been an issue forever. Q has so many questionable lines (game by game) and players out there in key situations that even some of the rah rah's get confused.
.
Now until things change............as sad as it is............You can forget another Cup until management gets their act together.
Are the Hawks a good team. Of course but to say this team will win the Cup with the talent they currently have is a real long shot. The season after this one should even be worse.
I don't particularly like any of them, although I suppose Raanta has potential to be solid if he can clean up the inconsistencies that plagued him last year.
This team is inextricably linked to Crawford at this point though. I'm not going to be concerned about filling a spot that won't be vacant for a long time when there are more pressing needs on the team.
David Rundblad was not a need for this team. He stinks, and is unlikely to turn into a good nhl player. This is just one example, but if we're going to be cavalier with our 2nd/3rd rounders, who more often than not don't turn into into good nhl players anyway, then why not gamble on a high-upside goalie?
Chicago's inability to generate even one good prospect from our late round goalie picks is not affirmation that the strategy is working. Quite the opposite.
What high upside goalies are there in the third? The whole Rundblad tangent is a head scratcher as well.
The strategy is taking skaters. It has worked, as evidenced by the roster. Taking goalies early right now is pointless with Crawford on his current contract.
Bowman is no Holland? You mean the guy who just signed Weiss last season and acquired the services of one Daniel Cleary again? You have it all figured out.
They've gotten NHL results with this strategy because at one time they picked a goalie in the 2nd who's worked out pretty well. At some point he will be gone, there is no one in the pipeline to take his place, and there's no reason to believe that we'll strike gold with a 7th rounder. The fact that people can name good goalies who were drafted late really has no bearing on our likelihood of accomplishing that.
The Hawks use to be Stanley Cup contenders NOW they are Stanley Cup pretenders.
Poor coaching and limited moves by Bowman to fill the holes with overspending gets you nothing but close. Close doesn't win Cups.
Name me one KEY addition that Bowman has made that been SIGNIFICANT? No #2 center like forever and the 3rd and 4th lines are not close to what they use to be. Bowman is no Holland and runs the show like a rookie G.M. Probably because that's how much talent he has.
Thanks to Q putting in Asst. coaches who operate just like him. The special teams has been an issue forever. Q has so many questionable lines (game by game) and players out there in key situations that even some of the rah rah's get confused.
.
Now until things change............as sad as it is............You can forget another Cup until management gets their act together.
Are the Hawks a good team. Of course but to say this team will win the Cup with the talent they currently have is a real long shot. The season after this one should even be worse.
I'm curious how you think that the 'hawks devolved so quickly:
IMHO the 'hawks will be in contention for the top 3 in the central and are poised to make another deep run.
- The assistant coach most responsible for the special teams' woes is gone.
- The #2C position has been addressed. Maybe it hasn't been ideally addressed but the team won 2 cups without one. By my count the last bonafied #2C our squad has was Robert Lang. That was before the bandwagon.
- Every single all-star caliber player is still on the squad--along with potentally all (or all but 1) Olympian. That is the bulk of of the top 6 FWDs and all of the Top-4 Dmen. That's not exactly like the team lost Roenik and had to replace him withy Vorobiev.
- The 'hawks lost in overtime of game 7 of the WCF - That's not exactly being overmatched. 2009 our boys were overmatched against a verteran RedWings squad. Last year an incredibly minor tweak could have sent our boys to the SCF.
Back on topic...
Still curious about the terms of Leighton's contract...
I sometimes imagine what it's like for fans of bad teams that waltz in here to see some of the complaints we have from time to time. I imagine it's akin to a starving kid from the third world overhearing a steakhouse patron complaining about ordering a medium rare steak but getting a medium instead.... Oh, and they serve Pepsi products instead of Coke?!? Damn it, everything's ruined!
Hawks are pretenders now? Well ****, somewhere between 25 (pessimistic) and 29 (optimistic) other teams are screwed next year by extension.
"In case an injury or anything else — an emergency — I'll be the call-up guy," Leighton said. "For me, it's just go down and play in Rockford. Obviously, I'd like to get called up and play in Chicago, but my mindset is to play my best hockey in Rockford for right now."
Thanks for pointing that out. For some reason I thought Holland's record as a G.M went WAY past Cleary and Weiss. I guess not. Boy, the insight I receive here.