Does he have to be? He's an elite-upside top 5 pick centreman. Those don't come cheap and Wings don't have one in their prospect pool unless Jarnkrok or Janmark wildly exceed expectations. If you look at the prospect depth chart I made if this trade were to happen, the Wings still have plenty of talent at every position. In this scenario, they have an elite level prospect at every position. Mrazek in goal, Sproul on the back end, Mantha on the wing and Lindholm at centre.
I think that's worth the price it would require.
Plus he's Jarnkrok's cousin so it'd be pretty cool to see them play together.
I think a lot of people over value some prospects. This is one such case.
Do I think he is a toews kane? NO. So your trade is just blah.
I laugh at you honestly elite use that word only when its true.
For Z and D please lol.
Not for sproul im sorry but a guy who struggles at own end is NOT ELITE on D. He is not Karlsson and doubtful ever will be.
We throw around things once in awhile wayyyyyy tooo easily.
Nyquist might wind up being ELITE category there is true signs. No one and I mean no one has shown they deserve that title in our prospect pool. Mrazek might be and I think he has a shot. Others might step up and surprise as you said. Mantha? I question him big time being Elite. Do I see him as the next getzlaf? I seriously doubt it.
We have a lot of good kids and time will tell who shakes it up and who doesnt.
Top 5 center pick Elite jeez Lindholm?
http://www.eliteprospects.com/player.php?player=33387
Nothing I see there tells me this guy is elite? Or could be Elite. I believe he is a hard worker and good kid and smart on the ice and does play decently two way game but to say he is RNH or galenchyuk or duchene tavares type?
I dont see where he has ever shown that yet.
So to give away 5-6 prospects and two picks REALLY?
He is 18 I assume lets give him some time before we decide he is worth trading 2-3 valuable assets and two early picks lol.
For the package you offered I would hope would be some interest in teams who would give one of those four above away honestly.