Discussion in 'Soccer' started by lud, Dec 30, 2018.
Vote and Discuss Here?
Ginola doesn't belong.
Another easy one. Ronaldo unfortunately.
Pavel Nedved for me. I rank him above Ronaldo, because he was much better in defense. He had no weakness in his game beside header. Anyway i see Ronaldo more as a deep-lying forward.
Nor does Ronaldo really.
Also, it's spelled Rivellino, not Rivelinho: Rivellino - Wikipedia
This is a tough position , laden with talent , to choose but ultimately comes down to Ronaldo and Giggs ....be a rock , paper , sissors imo
Ronaldo played LW at United in a 4-4-2, and LW in a 4-3-3 at Madrid beside Benezema.
How is he not a LW?
He doesn’t now, but peak Ronaldo was a LW.
I think these are interesting debates, but it’s quite hard to do when a good chunk of the voting pool has basically never seen some of these players.
Heck, most Americans don’t remember Ryan Giggs for any of his heyday.
I would say these types of debates are much better if you limit some of the scope to the last decade or two (though this one is better in that sense).
Ronaldo I could understand, but Giggs over Ronaldinho?
Nope. Heck Stoichkov was better. Blokhine, Rivelino. Heck, Neymar is better than Giggs, who was NEVER a top 5 player in his era.
How could you possibly hate Joe Sakic?
He traded away Matt Duchene
That explains it...
He's played at striker for so long that one hardly remembers those days. In his last seasons at United he was rarely seen at left wing anymore, but more upfront.
We all have our opinions .The only hardware that matters to me is 13 Premier League Titles , loyalty at one club . Thundering down the wing with th e ball tied, it seemed , to his foot . Many an inside midfielder had to leave his assignment to help contain Giggs , creating vast amounts of space for other players to get most of the other individual glory . I stick with my pick , thanks.
His brother might not agree with your loyalty and selflessness take......
I hate Man U , And I don't like Ryan Giggs ..., but football is football and I have my blinders on to anything else .
I've had a closer look at the poll - you don't mean the Portuguese Eder, do you?
Gordie Howe is my pick
Couldn't be , gotta be another one. We got The Portugal Eder on loan at Swansea and he hardly played .
Ya'll better be joking and not forgetting one of the GOATs from the 1982 Brazil squad.
Also, Giggs? Guy was never even the best player on his team. Doesn't belong in the conversation with the rest of these players.
He got more votes than 16 on the list so I guess 17 don't belong
Separate names with a comma.