Samsquanch said:
He keeps falling back to that one point. Yes I took exception to it at the time. But it's one of 3 or 4 different red flags that went up for me over the course of this whole event.
It's a lot more appropriate to say those things could very well have affected the hiring, instead of saying they had no bearing on it whatsoever, considering the fact that he didn't sign here...
But whatever, I'm just shocked that people can still stand behind them and try to justify the fact that we didn't want to give him the 4th year.
It's only going to make them look worse when Dorion gets up on stage and gives us a very shaky statement on why it didn't work out.
Why would I go back to points that I didn't take issue with? My critique was never about people being unsure if we could get a deal done, but with the irrational logic and demonizing of Melnyk for what shouldn't have been a concern. Admittedly the #Melnykphhobia thing was the result in growing increasingly tired with the absurd arguments getting thrown about (not you specifically, but collectively) and my have crossed the line towards being a bit childish myself, but frankly, when the conversation gets that absurd, a little humour is my way not losing my mind over how stupid some of the stuff around here can get.
I also don't see too many (if any) blindly trusting management. Most think that it was a mistake not to offer a 4th year. Some have suggested that management may have had reasons why they didn't do it, (ie the only logical reason we didn't offer it wasn't Melnyk, there are other possibilities), but few are saying it was the right choice from the info we are privy to.
You were right in your prediction in that we didn't end up landing Boudreau. Not sure that it has anything to do with us not being aggressive enough in our pursuit, though that may just have been a symptom of our risk adverse nature.
If this is a case were the Wild outbid what Dorion was willing to offer, only time will tell if it was a mistake or not to set the threshold too low, undervalued Boudreau (or overvalued the other options). If Dorion was willing to make the same offer, but was trying to get in a little lower first, then the blame rests solely on his shoulders for the miscue in not getting his target.