TSN: Fun little Marner game

[MagicalRazor]

Has anyone watched this little video? , what player would you pick if you're building a team , Marner or Player X

It's a fun little game , Salary cap doesn't exist if you were drafting them right now knowing what these players are capable of who would you take. age counts you're assuming your signing these players for 8 years. I'm curious to see who our fan base would take right now . Try not to be bias , It's a fun little summer time blues game

Marner OR Brayden point
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine
Marner OR David Pastrnak
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl
Marner OR Mark Scheifele
Marner OR Sasha barkov
Marner OR Elias Pettersson

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner OR Mathew Barzal
Marner OR Jack Eichel
Marner OR Taylor Hall
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon

Click to read more...

 

[MattySnipes]

MacK/Barkov/Rantanen are my choices.

 

[96]

Marner OR Brayden point - Point edit: actually I'd change this to Marner
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov - Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine - Marner
Marner OR David Pastrnak - Marner
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl - Marner
Marner OR Mark Scheifele - Marner
Marner OR Sasha barkov - Barkov
Marner OR Elias Pettersson - Marner

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov - Marner
Marner OR Mathew Barzal - Marner
Marner OR Jack Eichel - Marner
Marner OR Taylor Hall - Marner
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen - Rantanen due to size edit: maybe Id change this too
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon - MacKinnon

 

[IPS]

Bolded is my choice

Marner OR Brayden point
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine
Marner OR David Pastrnak
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl
Marner OR Mark Scheifele
Marner OR Sasha barkov
Marner OR Elias Pettersson

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner OR Mathew Barzal
Marner OR Jack Eichel
Marner OR Taylor Hall
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon

 

[WestCoastLeafs]

Marner OR Brayden point - Marner but it's close - Marner is a year younger and has done more, Point is a centre
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov - Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine - lol
Marner OR David Pastrnak - Marner
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl - probably Marner
Marner OR Mark Scheifele - in a vacuum Schiefele, but Marner when you have JT/AM down the middle
Marner OR Sasha barkov - Barkov based on reputation - haven't seen him much.
Marner OR Elias Pettersson - Pettersson

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov - Marner
Marner OR Mathew Barzal - Marner
Marner OR Jack Eichel - Eichel (pedigree + he plays on a garbage team, but Marner has shown more)
Marner OR Taylor Hall - Marner
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen - Rantanen
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon - MacKinnon

 

[Leafs at Knight]

Bolded is my choice

Marner OR Brayden point
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine
Marner OR David Pastrnak
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl
Marner OR Mark Scheifele
Marner OR Sasha barkov
Marner OR Elias Pettersson

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner OR Mathew Barzal
Marner OR Jack Eichel
Marner OR Taylor Hall
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon

Laine over Marner? Ouff. Which also means you think Laine is better than Pettersson

 

[Duke Silver]

Kucherov
MacKinnon
Draisaitl
Pastrnak
Scheifele
Barkov
Eichel
Point

Marner

Hall
Rantanen
Kuznetsov
Barzal
Laine
Pettersson

 

[Goose]

You lied. This is not fun.

 

[Scott Stevens]

I like: Kucherov, Scheifele, Barkov, Pettersson, MacKinnon over Marner.

I like Marner over: Laine, Pastrnak, Kuznetzov, Hall, Rantanen.

I like as a group I don’t feel comfortable picking from: Marner, Point, Draisaitl, Barzal, Eichel.

 

[MagicalRazor]

I guess I'll play
Marner < Brayden point
Marner > Nikita Kucherov
Marner >>>>>>>>>> Patrik Laine
Marner > David Pastrnak
Marner > Leon Draisaitl
Marner > Mark Scheifele
Marner < Sasha barkov
Marner < Elias Pettersson

Marner > Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner > Mathew Barzal
Marner > Jack Eichel Just because i absolutely dislike Eichel
Marner > Taylor Hall
Marner < Mikko Rantanen
Marner < Nathan MacKinnon

 

[Voodoo Child]

Point
Kucherov
Draisaitl
Barkov
Eichel
MacKinnon

So that's an elite as-productive C who's near-elite defensively, the best winger in the game who makes what Mitch should make, a big body 50 goal winger who can play C, another as-productive Selke C, a same age center who got 82 points but still has another gear and the second best young forward in the league.

Laine has exactly one tool, is streaky and seems not to want it bad enough.

Pasta has to produce away from Bergeron and Marchand.

I feel like we have a better version of Schiefele in Matthews already.

66 point Elias Petterson who is almost as good as McDavid?

Kuznetsov? He's five years older and has never gotten over 90 points.

Barzal would be wasted as a 3C.

Hall is too inconsistent year to year and has a lot of miles on him.

Rantanen plays with MacKinnon and got spoon-fed PP time and Mitch still outproduced him.

 

[ACC1224]

For the Leafs, none.
Barkov and MacKinnon if Matthews or JT weren't Leafs.

 

[Suntouchable13]

Why do people think that Marner is better than Drai exactly? I think that's homerism, tbh.

 

[Anthrax442]

Marner OR Brayden point
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine
Marner OR David Pastrnak
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl
Marner OR Mark Scheifele
Marner OR Sasha barkov
Marner OR Elias Pettersson

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner OR Mathew Barzal
Marner OR Jack Eichel
Marner OR Taylor Hall
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon

 

[Funk21]

Has anyone watched this little video? , what player would you pick if you're building a team , Marner or Player X

It's a fun little game , Salary cap doesn't exist if you were drafting them right now knowing what these players are capable of who would you take. age counts you're assuming your signing these players for 8 years. I'm curious to see who our fan base would take right now . Try not to be bias , It's a fun little summer time blues game

Marner OR Brayden point
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine
Marner OR David Pastrnak
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl
Marner OR Mark Scheifele
Marner OR Sasha barkov
Marner OR Elias Pettersson

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner OR Mathew Barzal
Marner OR Jack Eichel
Marner OR Taylor Hall
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon

Point
Kucherov
Marner
Tie
Drai
Scheifele
Barkov
Kuznetsov
Marner
Eichel
Marner
Rantanen
MacKinnon

As you can tell I value C position more than winger and I will take size and scoring in the case Rantanen. Laine has too many holes in his game at this point.

 

[Nithoniniel]

Marner OR Brayden Point
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine
Marner OR David Pastrnak
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl
Marner OR Mark Scheifele
Marner OR Sasha Barkov
Marner OR Elias Pettersson

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner OR Mathew Barzal
Marner OR Jack Eichel
Marner OR Taylor Hall
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon

 

[Nineteen67]

Point Kucherov MacKinnon Rantanen

 

[PromisedLand]

Great now substitute Marner for Nylander and Matthews and do the picks again

 

[al secord]

I started typing out my list, but I was having so much fun, my fingers exploded!

 

[Orfieus]

if Marner will only play for $11mx5yrs I wouldn't choose Marner over any of these players.

Not a single one

 

[Leafs1991]

Marner OR Brayden point
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov
Marner OR Patrik Laine
Marner OR David Pastrnak
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl
Marner OR Mark Scheifele
Marner OR Sasha barkov
Marner OR Elias Pettersson

Marner OR Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner OR Mathew Barzal
Marner OR Jack Eichel
Marner OR Taylor Hall
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon

 

[MyBudJT]

If Marner continues to develop similar to the average of the guys listed, I wouldnt be surprised to see Marner come out at or near the top of the list when we look back 20 years from now.

U22 seasons ranked:

Mitch Marner: 82GP 26G 94P
Taylor Hall 45GP 16G 50P

Mikko Rantanen 81GP 29G 84P
David Pastrnak 82GP 35G 80P
Jack Eichel 67GP 25G 64P
Leon Draisaitl 82GP 29G 77P

Sasha Barkov 61GP 21G 52P
Brayden point 82GP 32G 66P
Nikita Kucherov 82GP 29G 65P
Mathew Barzal 82GP 18G 62P

Nathan MacKinnon 82GP 16G 53P
Mark Scheifele 82GP 15G 49P
Evgeny Kuznetsov 17GP 3G 9P

Elias Pettersson NA
Patrik Laine NA

 

[ULF_55]

I am considering salary cap implication, since it does impact what you can do with the team.

Marner OR Brayden point - goals - but of course look at his supporting cast (same can be said for Marner though)
Marner OR Nikita Kucherov - goals and points and cap
Marner OR Leon Draisaitl - goals and overall game and cap
Marner OR Mark Scheifele - goals and overall game and wonderful cap hit
Marner OR Mikko Rantanen - goals and size but look at his center (same can be said for Marner though)
Marner OR Nathan MacKinnon - maybe it's Rantanen?

 

[ShaneFalco]

The answer is always "Marner"

 

[Craig Button]

I guess I'll play
Marner < Brayden point
Marner > Nikita Kucherov
Marner >>>>>>>>>> Patrik Laine
Marner > David Pastrnak
Marner > Leon Draisaitl
Marner > Mark Scheifele
Marner < Sasha barkov
Marner < Elias Pettersson

Marner > Evgeny Kuznetsov
Marner > Mathew Barzal
Marner > Jack Eichel Just because i absolutely dislike Eichel
Marner > Taylor Hall
Marner < Mikko Rantanen
Marner < Nathan MacKinnon

What???????