Erik Karlsson vs Luke Schenn

[Sensnation55]

Erik Karlsson vs Luke Shenn


Who will have the better carrer

Vs

Who will have the better carrer

Click to read more...

 

[Dutch Dreams]

Seriously? If you want to compare Ottawa and Toronto prospects then why not compare him to Cowen, who is a similar player?

This is like comparing Chris Campoli to Keith Aulie.

 

[bdp]

Who will have the better carrer

 

[Grabovski]

I don't know what a Carrer is so I can not answer this question.

 

[dubey]

Sounds like a type of chocolate. Mon petite carrer.

 

[Hermit Wizard Eater]

Karlsson. All Schenn really has on Karlsson is physical play and a slight edge in defensive play.

Karlsson's 40 points + that he'll have on Schenn every year makes him the superior defenseman.

 

[OperationHotMother]

I predict this thread will end with a clear consensus and no hurt feelings on either side!

 

[zoA]

Karlsson. All Schenn really has on Karlsson is physical play and a slight edge in defensive play.

Karlsson's 40 points + that he'll have on Schenn every year makes him the superior defenseman.

haha, that's cute. I'm also in line with the carrer fail in this thread.

 

[Lehner]

Karlssons good defensively too, so it is only slight.

 

[All Day*]

Karlssons good defensively too, so it is only slight.

And we are talking about in the future. So, think bigger.

 

[Dutch Dreams]

Carrer. That sounds French. Maybe that shows an Ottawa bias, haha...

Anyways, both have the potential to be top-pairing defensemen in this league, one a 2-way, shutdown guy and the other a straight-up offensive catalyst. They are the type of guys you make a pairing out of.

 

[Dutch Dreams]

And we are talking about in the future. So, think bigger.

Schenn is also developing offensively, so the same speculation can be applied to his weakness versus Karlsson's strength, which is offense.

 

[jgravessimcoe]

I predict this thread will end with a clear consensus and no hurt feelings on either side!

this.

Its apples and oranges really.
If they both reach their full potentials I'd take schenn. Really good physical shutdown guys are harder to come by than really good puck movers. Im also impressed by the head on his shoulders.
With that being said, its still anyones game and I think anyone would be happy to have either of these young guys.

 

[danishh]

apples and oranges.

Cowen/Schenn is a better comparison, but it's far too early to do that, since cowen hasnt even played in the NHL yet.

 

[mcphllp]

apples and oranges.

Cowen/Schenn is a better comparison, but it's far too early to do that, since cowen hasnt even played in the NHL yet.

1 gp

 

[mcphllp]

better comparison would be gunnarsson, imo

but i take schenn, he's that good

 

[VL]

I'm disappointed that no one has asked who Luke Shenn is. As others have pointed out though, why are we discussing his carrer (and what is a carrer anyway)?

 

[Dutch Dreams]

Gunnarsson has yet to show any elite offensive potential. He's more of a no. 4, big-minute, stabilizing defenseman.

 

[mlugia]

I heard Shenn is way better than Dustin Rose was at the same age.

 

[bzer]

This thread is so confusing as others have pointed out. Shenn? Carrer?

And also, Schenn is not a prospect anymore. The man has played almost 150 games in the NHL lol.

 

[Parise09*]

Karlsson easily.

 

[Hero]

Hard to compare but I think in their prime Karlsson will be better.

 

[CarknerCountry]

Karlsson vs Schenn....

Drafted in the same year.......who do you think is the better prospect? i know they are two different type of d-men.....But with the game being as it is today i have to go with Karlsson no disrespect to Schenn id love to have him on the sens....

 

[SpezDispenser]

Karlsson by a landslide.

 

[Midas0]

Look how good his shot from the point is, and look at the beautiful breakout pass. He's going to be a franchise player.

Karlsson wins this HUGE.