Phaneuf*
Guest
Hey guys I've been browsing these boards for ages and finally signed up and I've seen some of the vs topics. You all seem to know your hockey so I'd like to see your views on these players and who you think is better.
Phaneuf said:Hey guys I've been browsing these boards for ages and finally signed up and I've seen some of the vs topics. You all seem to know your hockey so I'd like to see your views on these players and who you think is better.
mpdman said:I'd take Dion over Suter. He really seems to be the complete package. I think I've seen him make just one mistake in 5 games, plus he has a mean streak (not as mean as Weber though....). He reminds me of Pronger.
Suter reminds me of Suter. His dad was super-skilled, but less dominant in his own zone. Ryan seems to cheap-shot less than Gary at least.
Both will be NHLers allstars for the next 15 years.
Drake1588 said:but feel that Suter is underrated.
Vlad The Impaler said:Underrated?! As of a few days ago, he was topping almost every prospect lists at the defenseman position.
It's not enough that people have been misguided enough to fall in love with that dude and proclaim him king of all D prospects, now you'd like me to believe he's underrated? :lol
When will Suter cease to be underrated exactly? When he sits as the #1 overall prospect?
For the last few months, Suter has received far more props than he deserves. He's overrated, not underrated.
Drake1588 said:I think there are three or four diehard Preds fans on HFboards who flog the heck out of Suter, but pretty much everyone else, myself included, would tend to prefer Phaneuf. Suter is very, very good, but Phaneuf is the better prospect and not too many people would argue that point.
AgentNaslund said:Phaneuf in a heartbeat. What has Suter done in this tournament? Phaneuf is making the type of impact, that no other defencemen at the world tourny's has done before. hes a hitting machine. A terminator. Suter is the typical, "hes got size, can skate, can move the puck around very well," type of defencemen. Yeah alot of defencemens are like that. Phaneuf over Suter. Infact, I will even take Seabrook over him.