My take:
The team looked like a group that was rusty, and was trying to open up the play on their own while defaulting to the old system quite a bit. Lots of dump-ins mixed with some very poor attempts at skating the puck into the zone. Passing was off, shooting was off, goalie rebound control was mediocre, etc, etc. All things you'd expect from the first preseason game.
In terms of specific players...
Nash held onto the puck way too long. I don't think he and Richards have the natural chemistry that Nash and Stepan do. Needs to be more decisive in driving to the net.
Richards looked alright. Calling him the best player on the ice, to me, is a stretch. He had some good moments, but plenty of boneheaded ones as well. He certainly doesn't seem to have much pace left in the tank, but his conditioning looked better. There was one chance in the 2nd where he was going for a change, but jumped back into the play when Nash pushed back the D and got a shot on goal. He probably wouldn't have had the gas for that last year.
Kreider was up and down. I thought he had some really good shifts, and also some really bad ones. That play where he couldn't bury the iced puck and then wasn't hard enough on Tedenby's stick leading to the first goal was certainly the low-point of the night, but I thought he rebounded well. I think he's a better fit with Brassard because they both have the pace to push back the D.
Hrivik and Kristo looked like kids playing at the highest level they've played. Tentative early, but looked more comfortable later. Hrivik is great along the boards, but Kristo definitely needs open ice to be effective. Liked the creativity from both.
Staal looked great given the circumstances. Maybe a step or two behind where he was last year, but still very, very good. Decisive with the puck and put several good shots on net. What a relief.
Del Zotto was okay. Looked rusty for sure, but made some nice plays. Dished out some solid hits too.
J. Moore was fantastic. I thought he started out trying to force some plays that weren't there, but if he continues his upward development, Del Zotto is going to need to be looking over his shoulder. Tremendous skater, great vision, and a very good shot from the point. Gap control was solid and he looked strong on the puck.
Falk was okay, but his recovery ability is god awful. Once he's out of the play, he's really out of the play. Needs to stop stepping up on odd-man rushes to make open-ice hits.
Talbot looked really impressive. Very square to the shooter, quick reflexes, and battles like a veteran goalie. Hopefully he can solidify himself as the heir to the backup position.
Mashinter looked good in his fight, and he hits like a train, but the dude cannot skate. Choppy stride, terrible edge work, and once he hits a guy behind the net on the forecheck, he's never going to make it back to the defensive zone in time to play D.