ChadS
Registered User
- Jun 30, 2009
- 4,865
- 1,476
Edvinsson said in his interview that last month he measured in at 199 cm so 6'6.35. I think at the draft he was 6'4...
I was thinking Joe Veleno.So you're saying he's more a Riley Sheahan?
Kinda like being upset that the All Star Game doesn't result in a 2-1 final score.You can't really draw conclusions from a 3v3 game.
Helm with hands?I was thinking Joe Veleno.
But....with handsSo you're saying he's more a Riley Sheahan?
Any stinkers? Heard not so good things about Edvinsson's and Cossa's performanceJust watched those games.
+++ Lombardi
++ Kasper
+ Savage
+ Sebrango
+ Viro
+ Wallinder
+ Gylander (best goalie)
At this rate he'll be 8 feet tall in a year!Edvinsson said in his interview that last month he measured in at 199 cm so 6'6.35. I think at the draft he was 6'4...
Any stinkers? Heard not so good things about Edvinsson's and Cossa's performance
In what I saw, Edvinsson looked like a dad playing with his kids. If he wanted to, he would have embarrassed some of them. His length and strength was noticeable. He could fend off any check just by keeping his body between the puck and the defender.Any stinkers? Heard not so good things about Edvinsson's and Cossa's performance
He was 6'5 at the draft but the athletic had an article mid last season that he was 6'6 now so that makes sense. Doesnt make sense how smooth of a skater he is at that sizeEdvinsson said in his interview that last month he measured in at 199 cm so 6'6.35. I think at the draft he was 6'4...
Edvinsson said in his interview that last month he measured in at 199 cm so 6'6.35. I think at the draft he was 6'4...
I caught the second half of the 2nd game for Cossa and he looked good in what I saw. His team won 4-2 and he made some nice saves. He did get scored on as soon as I turned the game on, but seemed to settle in after that. I did hear people say he looked bad in the first game though.
Thought Edvinsson looked really good despite it being completely obvious he was not playing with max effort. Just looks so refined, like a prototype top D prospect
Wallinder on the other hand was a tad disappointing from what I saw but it's a summer scrimmage so whatever
Edvinsson practically walked onto the ice from the tarmac. I'm sure he was pretty sleepy and jetlagged. He still looked pretty good.Both Wallinder and Edvinsson weren't even really trying.
Also of note, Wallinder lost his baggage and was using someone else's skates. That's never a good feeling.
It's one day, so it is what it is.You can't really draw conclusions from a 3v3 game.
Agree with much of this assessment. A few things I see differently:Impressed by:
* Viro - Smooth, quick, effective
* Lombardi - WTF level good in the first game. Invisible in game 2
* Kasper - Skates like a top liner. Showed some skill. Skill isn't elite.
* Ali - Not a lot of skill, but he pushed the play constantly. Probably only above average speed. But never stops moving.
* Savage - Kind of the same. Skill is kind of there. Speed is good. Intensity wasn't quite what Ali showed.
* Plandowski - Played like his draft day scouting reports read. Smooth. Speedy. Creative.
* Sebrango - Probably the best player in the tournament. He was so active and involved in the rush I couldn't believe it was Sebrango.
Looked OK
* Edvinsson - Stood out because of his size. I don't know if his stick skills and processing is ready for the NHL just yet.
* Niederbach - Flashed some skill but didn't really stand out.
* Dower-Nilsson - Showed a shot and some skill. But didn't stand out.
* Phillips - Showed speed but not a lot of skill.
* Buium - Moves well, when he's not falling. Didn't see much skill.
Disappointed by:
* Mazur - Nothing was working.
* James - Ditto
* Hanas - This should have been a chance for him to shine. He didn't.
* Wallinder - Kind of like Edvinsson - but less involved.
* Cossa - Whenever I see him in a Wings or Team Canada jersey, it just doesn't go well. Reactions seem a little slow.
* Mastrosimone - Inconsistent skill - sometimes he had great hands, lots of times he struggled. But I'm worried about that skating.
Nothing really blew me away or changed perceptions very much.
Lombardi did enough to make me wonder if he's something to watch - when previously I simply didn't care about him.
I get the impression that anyone expecting Edvinsson to mirror Seider's year is in for a disappointment. He'll get to the NHL, but he looked pretty raw in Brobergian fashion.
I've had some doubts about Cossa since the rookie tournament and the WJCs. I have to say one takeaway from this tournament is I'm starting to wonder if he's the sure thing I thought he was.
Cossa doesn't turn 20 for another 4 months. So as a 19yo D+1 WHL Champion goaltender who was drafted #15 and not Top 5, I'd say he's right where ne needs to be. Still has at least 3-4 years until he sniffs the NHL.Agree with much of this assessment. A few things I see differently:
- Lombardi wasn’t invisible the 2nd game. He was actually much involved and they made sure he was on the ice with the goalie pulled. I think he set a pretty insurmountable bar in game 1.
- Edvinsson looked like a guy who showed up last minute to a shinny, and probably felt like trying uber hard against lower competition could only hurt his stock. I’ve seen him play enough to know he was on cruise control.
- I was actually pretty impressed with James and Mazur. 3 on 3 isn’t their style of game, but the attributes I was looking for were evident at times. Speed, grit, with some offensive spurts.
- Hanas was making plays and while the stat sheet doesn’t show it, you could see he is head and shoulders above most prospects in terms of vision, craftiness, and pure skill. He and Kasper looked great together.
- Cossa scares me. Dude looks shaky and seems to lack confidence. Hoping just an off day.
Cossa doesn't turn 20 for another 4 months. So as a 19yo D+1 WHL Champion goaltender who was drafted #15 and not Top 5, I'd say he's right where ne needs to be. Still has at least 3-4 years until he sniffs the NHL.
Yep...I was going by him and Demko in VancouverJake Oettinger (1st rounder in 2017) is probably your closest recent comparable that's now in line to be the starting goalie. Drafted in 2017 and got starts on the tail end of 2020-2021 (but those starts came out of injury woes). Even this season, he still played 10 AHL games.
So with that timeline, we're looking at 2025ish for him to get some NHL action rolling. A solid 3 years in front of us with at least 2 years in the AHL.