Proposal: Det - Chi

[LDF]

A Bhawk / Det trade idea.

This trade for Det to continue help with the Salary Cap going into the off-season while at the same time helping in putting prospects in the overall Det org.

to Det

Connor Murphy - RHD, Gustav Forsling – LHD, Brendan Perlini – Winger, Dylan Sikura – Center, Victor Ejdsell – Center,


to Bhawks

Mike Green – RHD, Anthony Mantha – RW , Darren Helm, Filip Zadina – LW, 2019 1st rou pick – top 5 protected if not then 2020 1st rounder no protection, Plus 2019 3rd rounder.

Click to read more...

 

[Big Ed]

am i missing something? that's awful

 

[izlez]

As a red wings fan, who is possibly as low on Zadina as anyone on this whole board... what in the hell is this???

 

[BleedBlue14]

The formatting is almost as bad as the idea.

 

[LDF]

well i guess it is a one sided idea favoring the Bhawks, but i was thinking of salary dump per se for det.

 

[Edison]

I bet Holland blocks bowmans number after this proposal.

 

[BStinson]

Put the beer down

 

[LDF]

I bet Holland blocks bowmans number after this proposal.

funny .... humor i like it.

 

[Edison]

well i guess it is a one sided idea favoring the Bhawks, but i was thinking of salary dump per se for det.

Those det players are good players with value, not cap dumps.

 

[LDF]

Those det players are good players with value, not cap dumps.

but with Det back against the cap wall and those players mention will ease the cap.

ref to the Bhawks player, they too are real value as an up and coming prospect with some really high projection.

 

[izlez]

well i guess it is a one sided idea favoring the Bhawks, but i was thinking of salary dump per se for det.

1. We don't need a salary dump
2. Where is the salary dump? Green? Who is by far our best defenseman on a pretty reasonable, short contract? Mantha? Who is one of our best, youngest forwards, on a pretty reasonable contract?
3. This is REALLY one sided. I'm not sure I would make this trade for any one of the four pieces going the other way. And then, you didn't add one piece, you didn't add 2 pieces, you added 3 more high end pieces.

 

[LDF]

1. We don't need a salary dump
2. Where is the salary dump? Green? Who is by far our best defenseman on a pretty reasonable, short contract? Mantha? Who is one of our best, youngest forwards, on a pretty reasonable contract?
3. This is REALLY one sided. I'm not sure I would make this trade for any one of the four pieces going the other way. And then, you didn't add one piece, you didn't add 2 pieces, you added 3 more high end pieces.

i change the Mantha with darren helms.

 

[TCNorthstars]

but with Det back against the cap wall and those players mention will ease the cap.

ref to the Bhawks player, they too are real value as an up and coming prospect with some really high projection.

Detroit doesn't care about the Cap. They have plenty coming off at the end of the year.

Which of those Hawks players has a really high projection? Higher than Zadina? Higher than a really really good 1st round pick? Higher than Mantha? c'mon. You must be smoking one of those cocaine laced joints right now.

 

[LDF]

Detroit doesn't care about the Cap. They have plenty coming off at the end of the year.

Which of those Hawks players has a really high projection? Higher than Zadina? Higher than a really really good 1st round pick? Higher than Mantha? c'mon. You must be smoking one of those cocaine laced joints right now.

no not higher than Zadina but oh well.

 

[obey86]

I think this is quite possibly the worst trade proposal (by far) I have ever seen on this message board. Mike Green, Anthony Mantha, Filip Zadina, Darren Helm, a lottery pick, and a 3rd round pick for a bunch of crap players? What the hell? Might as well have the Wings throw in Cholowski, Hronek, and Rasmussen for Luke Johnson in return while you're at it.

 

[Wayne Primeau]

this might be the worst proposal i have ever seen

 

[LDF]

ok i guess you guys didn't like the idea.

well i am here is accept the skewering that i am getting.

 

[Tatar Shots]

Wow. This is almost as bad as Chicago paying Debrincat to dump Kane on Detroit for Dekeyser.

 

[echlfreak]

If Chicago is going to try to make a run? Would Detroit do:

Detroit gets
Hayden, young physical C/RW
Forsling, promising puck moving/mobile D
Kruger, fill in for Helm and then can keep or dump him
Edjsell, 6'5" C having some struggles this year but was solid in AHL playoffs last year

Chicago gets
Green, proven-reasonably priced puck moving D
Helm, veteran C who can round out 3rd/4th line

 

[Mrfenn92]

Not a good deal from Detroit's side at all.
Hawks would take it and run.

 

[Tatar Shots]

If Chicago is going to try to make a run? Would Detroit do:

Detroit gets
Hayden, young physical C/RW
Forsling, promising puck moving/mobile D
Kruger, fill in for Helm and then can keep or dump him
Edjsell, 6'5" C having some struggles this year but was solid in AHL playoffs last year

Chicago gets
Green, proven-reasonably priced puck moving D
Helm, veteran C who can round out 3rd/4th line

Chicago would have to convince both players to waive their NTCs. I would be ok with this deal from Detroit’s end

 

[WingsMJN2965]

This has to be a troll... What the f*** is this?

 

[Goalie guy]

Lol haha haha omg, How about you guys take Big Rig, Helm, Abby, Frk, Vanek, and give us Towes, Kane, Anisimov. Sound good. It will help your guys next 20 year rebuild.

 

[HawkeyTalkMan]

This is all around cancer

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

A Bhawk / Det trade idea.

This trade for Det to continue help with the Salary Cap going into the off-season while at the same time helping in putting prospects in the overall Det org.

to Det

Connor Murphy - RHD, Gustav Forsling – LHD, Brendan Perlini – Winger, Dylan Sikura – Center, Victor Ejdsell – Center,


to Bhawks

Mike Green – RHD, Anthony Mantha – RW , Darren Helm, Filip Zadina – LW, 2019 1st rou pick – top 5 protected if not then 2020 1st rounder no protection, Plus 2019 3rd rounder.

LMFAO So Detroit by far gives up the best pieces in the deal? No way Green waive for Chicago and we're not dealing Zadina unless Detroit boy Debrincat is coming the other way. This is total trash for Detroit. And Holland just blocked Bowmans number.