As much as this irritates me, it's hard to disagree with his stance on the actual roster.
If it were my money, Johnston and co. would be gone, but only in favor of a more experienced coach, of which there are many available. Morehouse, Guerin, Botterill, Karmanos, etc. would be gone. Rutherford would get a stern talking to and I would need to have confidence in him going forward. If not, he gets replaced ASAP.
That said, the actual roster just needs to cut dead weight and make a couple risks to get back to contender-status. Doing something crazy like moving Malkin is just suicidal for the franchise. Kunitz and Scuderi need to go, however possible. Seriously shop Sutter. Only re-sign Comeau out of the UFAs. And try to get a couple young wingers in some trades (honestly, it might mean moving Pouilot if we want a good one). And give Dumoulin-Harrington the reigns for the 3rd pair, Sundqvist on the 3rd line. Try to sign some promising KHLers or NCAAers - go after one of them hard, preferably Panarin.
It simply takes the right moves to get us out of this. We're not a lost cause yet. But this offseason is pivotal. And I wouldn't trust the Pittsburgh 9 with my lunch money, let alone an NHL roster. That's where the real problem lies.