Balance
Jesus loves you!
- May 20, 2013
- 2,568
- 1,106
I'm taking "current Matthews" as 2017-2018 Matthews, because to judge him on a 5 game sample size is lunacy. So basically both were PPG players, but Toews had Selke caliber defense. So yeah, not sure how this is a debate.
And even to start this year, Toews has more ES points than Matthews so far.
I get where you are coming from for sure so can't rag on this too hard but I would say that Matthews is one of the best defensive centers in the league so I don't consider better defensively as some "gotcha" especially when you see how talented offensively he is - in a lot of cases multiple times more talented than a guy like Toews.
Of course he has to prove it but this is a player like McDavid in that when you watch them, even if it was only one game, you realize this is someone at the top of their sport. Tavares is elite and good, but he doesn't stand out in that way.
Even if this was true, Toews was actually winning the Selke and was consistently in the top-5 in voting. Matthews didn't even get a vote for the Selke last year. Regardless of anyone's opinion on the bolded, Toews actually has the award showing he's one of the best defensive players in the league. Matthews doesn't.
I don't know what to think of Matthews defensively, I don't think he's as good defensively as Leafs fans say, but I'm not sure how good he actually is. The advanced stats results don't match the claims for me.
You have to consider who he's played with so far. Why do you think his defensive play has been praised so much by everyone in the game? Barkov said last season he was the hardest center to match up against, tsn panel said he was 2nd in defensive plays to Bergeron. None of this means he's the 2nd best defensively because I'm pretty sure he's not, but it means he's extremely good at it.
I never said he wasn't good defensively, I just don't know how good he is. I don't buy he's this amazing defensive center near the top of the league, because the results just don't say that. That doesn't mean he sucks defensively, I just don't buy that he has Selke caliber defense.
In this poll, it's a PPG player with Selke caliber defense vs a PPG player without Selke caliber defense, it's a really easy question.
Even if this was true, Toews was actually winning the Selke and was consistently in the top-5 in voting. Matthews didn't even get a vote for the Selke last year. Regardless of anyone's opinion on the bolded, Toews actually has the award showing he's one of the best defensive players in the league. Matthews doesn't.
I don't know what to think of Matthews defensively, I don't think he's as good defensively as Leafs fans say, but I'm not sure how good he actually is. The advanced stats results don't match the claims for me.
I'm taking "current Matthews" as 2017-2018 Matthews, because to judge him on a 5 game sample size is lunacy. So basically both were PPG players, but Toews had Selke caliber defense. So yeah, not sure how this is a debate.
And even to start this year, Toews has more ES points than Matthews so far.
I love when people do thisI'm taking "current Matthews" as 2017-2018 Matthews, because to judge him on a 5 game sample size is lunacy. So basically both were PPG players, but Toews had Selke caliber defense. So yeah, not sure how this is a debate.
And even to start this year, Toews has more ES points than Matthews so far.
Peak Toews. Not even close.
Too much recency bias and homerism on here after a great 5 game stretch for Matthews. The board is becoming a bit of a joke.
I wouldn’t say ‘insane’. Just not a very reasonable position.Peak Toews was my favourite player (alongside Ovi), and was my dream C for the leafs.
The fact that Matthews is comparable (and significantly better imo) is insane
For people critical of the comparison what type of season would Matthews have to have for this to be close? Like if you like he’ll finish with 40+40 then maybe it’s a silly poll, but if you think he’ll finish with 50+50 then maybe it’s close.
Defensive beast?Wait, don't you mean the other way around? Toews career high is 76 points and he topped 70 once. If Matthews stays healthy he'll blow that crap out of the water while being a defensive beast himself.