Losing to strong Pens teams that went on to
win the SC or strong contenders like NYR is "choking". By your definition of choking, about half the teams that make the playoffs each year "choked". I think the Caps have somewhat
underachieved in the playoffs, chocking is one of those overused sports board pejoratives.
I doubt the Caps repeat b/c there is much parity in the NHL and upsets are relatively common in hockey. Amazes me how many fans act like it's still a 6 or 12 team league. Just extremely difficult to win four straight playoff series - even if you have one of the leagues better reg seasons. Currently Bolts (#1), Leafs, Preds, Jets, Flames too, are having strong reg seasons. However
at best only one will win the SC... the other four will have choked