You might get Paul for that but Brown and Zub are quite low vs what they could get on the open market.
If they want to drain every dollar possible (a bit like Brady did), then yeah they're gone.
At the same time, I don't think Zub is worth that much more in terms of AAV. I mean, look at that for example :
Christopher Tanev Contract, Cap Hit, Salary and Stats - CapFriendly - NHL Salary Caps
Browse - CapFriendly - NHL Salary Caps
As for Brown, yes he could get Hyman money. Danault was considered "overpaid" at 5.5 and he's a Selke level center. Pageau got 5.0. Great 2-way players don't make as much as elite ones (ex : Mark Stone, etc) so IMO Brown is at the level of these players I have named. Unless he reduces the term, I can't see him getting over 5.5 AAV so that's why I am hopeful he takes 5.0 AAV to stay in Ottawa
If he asks 6.0+ AAV, he's gone
Just let them boom and dry up all 5-6 of their RFA years before offloading them if they're actual legit top 6 F top 4 D, unlike trying to get a quick ROI like we did with Zib. Go the JGP route. Bridge bridge bridge until we realize they're playing above a level were able to afford and get back some good assets.
So for Formy, 2 years low cap. Reassess, then if anything 2-3 years and reassess again. We have the luxury of having out core already in Norris/Bath/Stu/Tkachuk. If in their prime we need to trade Formenton hopefully Greig and/or Boucher/other 1st/2nd_ rounders are contributing on their trail ELC/bridge by then.
Absolutely and you need a very good GM with foresight to manage this carefully. At some point, you need to be able to project players into the future. Their floor, their peak, their longevity, their health (of course non one has control on this but some players are built more "solid" and/or are less "injury prone"), their potential decline, etc. I'm not saying it's super easy but that's why NHL GM is an Elite executive job.
You need to do that with players like Hoffman and Dzingel for example and also why you always need some good players to emerge from your pool. You need an Alex Formenton to replace a Dzingel that you trade without missing a beat (or almost)
So basically, there's some players that you will want to keep their whole career, some that you will want to keep their whole 20's, some that you will want to trade by the 26/27 age... etc
Personally I see it as a dual core for forwards.
Main core : Batherson, Stutzle, Norris, Tkachuk (two PPG forwards and two 30 goals scorers?)
Support core : C. Brown, Formenton, N. Paul (need to be great 2-way players with some versatility)
For Greig and Pinto, we're not sure yet which core they'll belong to, we'll see. For many other guys, they'll fight to prove their worth and if they should be part of these groups. We have pretty much all our main guys, maybe there'll be another spot available. A high profile stop gap (like Giroux) would be very nice too