Speculation: Caps Roster General Discussion (Coaching/FAs/Cap/Lines etc) - 2022-23 Season Part 3: Drop the puck!

Status
Not open for further replies.

IafrateOvie34

Registered User
May 14, 2009
12,123
8,919
I liked both AFJ and Leason and always push for the young players if they have a chance. If it means losing both for Protas to make the NHL, well I'm for Protas! I believe he'll be a fine NHL player, is very intelligent, and his interview skills is above many NHL players already!
 

Ridley Simon

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Feb 27, 2002
18,373
9,367
Marin County — SF Bay Area, CA
Nothing surprising about the lineup really. The third line is probably not the advantage they believe it to be (or that it should be).

But, man, once Wilson returns it's going to be a lot of beef up front should Protas continue to belong.
Question is, who moves to LW when Willy returns? And who sits? Marge or Protas, is my guess. Hopefully Protas will be so good, it won’t be him.

They’d best put Mantha on his natural side. Then the 3rd line with Oshie will have some real teeth to it, what with either Protas or Mantha as the LW.

So many options. Put Willy back as 1RW, then where does Brown go? 2RW w Strome? Mantha or Protas as 2LW? The other is 3LW?

Pretty cool to mix and match.
 

Ovechkins Wodka

Registered User
Dec 1, 2007
17,688
7,401
DC
Question is, who moves to LW when Willy returns? And who sits? Marge or Protas, is my guess. Hopefully Protas will be so good, it won’t be him.

They’d best put Mantha on his natural side. Then the 3rd line with Oshie will have some real teeth to it, what with either Protas or Mantha as the LW.

So many options. Put Willy back as 1RW, then where does Brown go? 2RW w Strome? Mantha or Protas as 2LW? The other is 3LW?

Pretty cool to mix and match.
Someone will be hurt. But its fun to think we will have a full team at some point

I think Willy back with 8 and 92 unless Brown kills it on line 1
 

Corby78

65 - 10 - 20
Jan 14, 2014
11,781
7,998
Ramstein Germany
Hate that we lost Leasin and AJF. Would have been nice to see them in Hershey and still have some options down there. But they weren’t going to play here this year so….
 

Portable Mink

Registered User
Sep 12, 2005
7,053
2,363
Melbourne, Australia
This is going to sound weird but I miss Vrana being the outlier for speed and finish. As a big strong heavy team, Vrana was able to catch defense off-guard by being quicker thank what they expect most of the time. I feel like we are missing that kinda of player from our top 6-9.
 

Ovechkins Wodka

Registered User
Dec 1, 2007
17,688
7,401
DC
This is going to sound weird but I miss Vrana being the outlier for speed and finish. As a big strong heavy team, Vrana was able to catch defense off-guard by being quicker thank what they expect most of the time. I feel like we are missing that kinda of player from our top 6-9.
But he never could score and would just miss all his breakaways
 

twabby

Registered User
Mar 9, 2010
13,771
14,713


Neat little visualization that looks at the timing of goals given up, rather than just raw numbers. Basically weighing "backbreaking" goals against more than garbage time goals. Who cares if a goalie gives up a softie if the score is already 6-0, for instance. But giving up a cheap goal against in a tie game in the third period really stings.

Turns out Washington's goalies performed really poorly in this metric! Only PHI, BUF, and MTL did worse.

Micah estimates goaltending lost ~10 standings points for Washington last year, even if cumulatively they were only slightly worse than average. That's uh a lot. If they even get average goaltending this year they should be comfortably in the postseason, and perhaps pushing 105-110 points.
 
Last edited:

kicksavedave

I'm just here for the memes and gifs.
Sponsor
Apr 29, 2009
10,887
13,688
Fallbrook, CA
www.tiasarms.org
Turns out Washington's goalies performed really poorly in this metric! Only PHI, BUF, and MTL did worse.

Micah estimates goaltending lost ~10 standings points for Washington last year, even if cumulatively they were only slightly worse than average. That's uh a lot. If they even get average goaltending this year they should be comfortably in the postseason, and perhaps pushing 105-110 points.

This matches the eye test. There were games where either IS or VV would play very well, the Caps would get a 3-1 or 4-2 lead, then they would give up dreadful crap goals in the 3rd period to let the other team back in it. Or they would give up 3 early in the 1st then tighten up a lot over the last 50 minutes and still lose 4-3. And I've said for YEARS now that the measure of a great goalie is not how many great saves them make, its how many softies they DON'T allow. Softies demolish a teams momentum, it crushes their energy, it lets a team that doesn't deserve to be in the game, have a chance to win it. A poorly timed softie is a death knell in hockey. Great goalies make ALL the saves they are supposed to make, and a handful of spectacular saves. Poor goalies make a few spectacular saves and give up a handful of goals that beer leaguers should stop. That was us last year.
 

Hivemind

We're Touched
Oct 8, 2010
37,130
13,654
Philadelphia
This matches the eye test. There were games where either IS or VV would play very well, the Caps would get a 3-1 or 4-2 lead, then they would give up dreadful crap goals in the 3rd period to let the other team back in it. Or they would give up 3 early in the 1st then tighten up a lot over the last 50 minutes and still lose 4-3. And I've said for YEARS now that the measure of a great goalie is not how many great saves them make, its how many softies they DON'T allow. Softies demolish a teams momentum, it crushes their energy, it lets a team that doesn't deserve to be in the game, have a chance to win it. A poorly timed softie is a death knell in hockey. Great goalies make ALL the saves they are supposed to make, and a handful of spectacular saves. Poor goalies make a few spectacular saves and give up a handful of goals that beer leaguers should stop. That was us last year.
VV giving up a softy goal in the first 10 minutes and then tightening up for the rest of the game was a special of his. There was a stretch in mid-season where it happened in like 5 or 6 consecutive starts for him.
 

Corby78

65 - 10 - 20
Jan 14, 2014
11,781
7,998
Ramstein Germany


Neat little visualization that looks at the timing of goals given up, rather than just raw numbers. Basically weighing "backbreaking" goals against more than garbage time goals. Who cares if a goalie gives up a softie if the score is already 6-0, for instance. But giving up a cheap goal against in a tie game in the third period really stings.

Turns out Washington's goalies performed really poorly in this metric! Only PHI, BUF, and MTL did worse.

Micah estimates goaltending lost ~10 standings points for Washington last year, even if cumulatively they were only slightly worse than average. That's uh a lot. If they even get average goaltending this year they should be comfortably in the postseason, and perhaps pushing 105-110 points.

My nice visualization was watching it unfold all season.
 

g00n

Retired Global Mod
Nov 22, 2007
30,689
14,878


Neat little visualization that looks at the timing of goals given up, rather than just raw numbers. Basically weighing "backbreaking" goals against more than garbage time goals. Who cares if a goalie gives up a softie if the score is already 6-0, for instance. But giving up a cheap goal against in a tie game in the third period really stings.

Turns out Washington's goalies performed really poorly in this metric! Only PHI, BUF, and MTL did worse.

Micah estimates goaltending lost ~10 standings points for Washington last year, even if cumulatively they were only slightly worse than average. That's uh a lot. If they even get average goaltending this year they should be comfortably in the postseason, and perhaps pushing 105-110 points.


Moose out front already told me
 

twabby

Registered User
Mar 9, 2010
13,771
14,713
Moose out front already told me

1665607896537.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: g00n

IafrateOvie34

Registered User
May 14, 2009
12,123
8,919
This matches the eye test. There were games where either IS or VV would play very well, the Caps would get a 3-1 or 4-2 lead, then they would give up dreadful crap goals in the 3rd period to let the other team back in it. Or they would give up 3 early in the 1st then tighten up a lot over the last 50 minutes and still lose 4-3. And I've said for YEARS now that the measure of a great goalie is not how many great saves them make, its how many softies they DON'T allow. Softies demolish a teams momentum, it crushes their energy, it lets a team that doesn't deserve to be in the game, have a chance to win it. A poorly timed softie is a death knell in hockey. Great goalies make ALL the saves they are supposed to make, and a handful of spectacular saves. Poor goalies make a few spectacular saves and give up a handful of goals that beer leaguers should stop. That was us last year.
This, so glad last season is done.
 

DWGie26

Registered User
Sponsor
Oct 6, 2019
3,562
3,660
NOVA
Well i don’t want to panic but this is bad hockey. I do love Fever thought and that is my next jersey.

I think you put in both Snively and CMM as a radical change. I’d also move Mantha to 1RW (even though he looked lazy to me in what i have seen), and pair Brown with Strome (and Protas).

But as is… bad!
 
  • Like
Reactions: barriers

RVACapsFan

Registered User
May 31, 2018
439
728
If this is the year we fall off, what does the deadline look like? We have a ton of pending UFAs and Strome is an RFA. Other than Orlov I think they'd all be on the block. Orlov is still a solid D-man and by all accounts loves it in DC, so I could see him re-upping with us.

I do wonder what the market could look like for Carlson at the deadline. He has a 10-team NTC and three years left after this season at $8M AAV. Man it would be a gift to get out of the end of the contract.
 

Kuz

Registered User
May 11, 2015
1,093
651
If this is the year we fall off, what does the deadline look like? We have a ton of pending UFAs and Strome is an RFA. Other than Orlov I think they'd all be on the block. Orlov is still a solid D-man and by all accounts loves it in DC, so I could see him re-upping with us.

I do wonder what the market could look like for Carlson at the deadline. He has a 10-team NTC and three years left after this season at $8M AAV. Man it would be a gift to get out of the end of the contract.

At least its probably the best draft since McDavid's draft. So if they should fall off it could kickstart their rebuild.

I guess Caps will start to do better soon, but if not Brown, Strome, Eller, Jensen, Hathaway, Sheary, Johansson and TVR should all be available at 50% to increase their value in a trade.

Right now they need to switch up the lines. 1st line are not producing and giving up a lot of goals (All are -3).
 

Misery74

Registered User
Nov 20, 2017
2,280
2,184
Over/Under on Laviolette being fired should be Thanksgiving.

Hoping for Under. The guy is f***ing terrible.
 

Roughing

Registered User
Oct 11, 2010
1,942
303
Frederick, MD
Carlson is brutal. The money going to him, Backstrom, and Eller (at least) is completely wasted. And Blaine Forsythe should have been fired years ago. That guy sucks something awful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad