Brad Marchand or Corey Perry

[PatriceBergeronFan]

Brad Marchand - Wikipedia



Five suspensions and numerous fines. He's dirty.

Majority of which are earlier in his career. Face it, he's a pest and also is honed in on by the league for it. You don't see Subban with fines and suspensions for slew foots or "dangerous trips".

Since 2015 he's had one noteworthy instance (the spear) and Dotchin is a noted pest himself.

 

[The Macho King]

Majority of which are earlier in his career. Face it, he's a pest and also is honed in on by the league for it. You don't see Subban with fines and suspensions for slew foots or "dangerous trips".

He was suspended and fined last season. He has been suspended each of the past two seasons.

The defense of him is mindboggling. He's too good of a player to be so dirty - it's obnoxious.

 

[PatriceBergeronFan]

He was suspended and fined last season. He has been suspended each of the past two seasons.

The defense of him is mindboggling. He's too good of a player to be so dirty - it's obnoxious.

It's fantastic! This movement towards friendly and safe, emotionless hockey is a dark trend of late.

 

[duxfan1101]

Love em both

 

[The Macho King]

It's fantastic! This movement towards friendly and safe, emotionless hockey is a dark trend of late.

As a fan of a team who had Marc Savard's career ruined by a dirty player, I think it's pathetic and hypocritical of you to hold that opinion.

 

[PatriceBergeronFan]

As a fan of a team who had Marc Savard's career ruined by a dirty player, I think it's pathetic and hypocritical of you to hold that opinion.

Marchand has one elbowing headshot in his suspension history I do believe....

 

[Trap Jesus]

They're pretty much equal, Perry is just a lot more subtle in how he aggravates his opponents.

 

[NDiesel]

As a fan of a team who had Marc Savard's career ruined by a dirty player, I think it's pathetic and hypocritical of you to hold that opinion.

It will be hypocritical when Marchand ends a career...has he even injured a guy from any of his suspensions?

Side note, I love both players and any player identified as a pest.

 

[Ainec]

Marchand has one elbowing headshot in his suspension history I do believe....

He is one of the, if not the dirtiest player still active in the league

no harm in admitting that, and it doesn't diminish how much of a dominant player he's become

 

[Lazlo Hollyfeld]

argument with son, who is more despised?

It all comes down to "despised by who exactly?"

In the Western Conference it's probably Perry. In the East, Marchand. They're both rats.

For me personally I despise Perry more but there's no real rational reason why. I guess over the years I've watched firsthand him making more dirty plays than I have with Marchand.

 

[Byrral]

This is close. Should have been a poll. I actually like Perry and would take him on my team so that's my vote.

 

[Mr Tadakichi]

Glad Marchand wasn't around to play the Oilers earlier.

 

[hirawl]

More despised? Among hockey fans it's close but it's Marchand. Among their peers it's not close and it's Marchand.

 

[yangmang]

but honestly neither

 

[PatriceBergeronFan]

He is one of the, if not the dirtiest player still active in the league

no harm in admitting that, and it doesn't diminish how much of a dominant player he's become

Is that based on a reputation from earlier in his career? In recent years as a superstar, he has a "mean trip" and spearing another rat between the legs. Not so terrible.

 

[Fatty McLardy]

It's fantastic! This movement towards friendly and safe, emotionless hockey is a dark trend of late.

That's great and all, though i suspect you're one of those fans that cries wolf if someone pulls dirty stuff on your team despite the fake bravado online...

 

[Ainec]

Is that based on a reputation from earlier in his career? In recent years as a superstar, he has a "mean trip" and spearing another rat between the legs. Not so terrible.

Watch: Bruins' Brad Marchand gets away with yet another slew foot - Sportsnet.ca
Brad Marchand fined $10,000 for slew foot on Niklas Kronwall - Sportsnet.ca

back to back 2017

Cooke eventually stopped. Marchand I think realises that he's under a microscope. A 5-8 game suspension is too much of a deterrence

 

[MapleLeafistan]

Brad Marchand or Corey Perry


Answer: Brad Perry

 

[eternalbedhead]

I miss the days back when this was Perry's title. It's Marchand's now.

 

[Plural]

Marchand is dirtier, Perry is bigger d-bag.

 

[PatriceBergeronFan]

Watch: Bruins' Brad Marchand gets away with yet another slew foot - Sportsnet.ca
Brad Marchand fined $10,000 for slew foot on Niklas Kronwall - Sportsnet.ca

back to back 2017

Cooke eventually stopped. Marchand I think realises that he's under a microscope. A 5-8 game suspension is too much of a deterrence

If comparing Marchand to Cooke in a favorable tone to Cooke the conversation ends there.

 

[Ainec]

If comparing Marchand to Cooke in a favorable tone to Cooke the conversation ends there.

where did u see that

 

[CalgarySnow]

I have to say personally Kesler is my most despised, funny how nearly all my most despised players played for the Cassucks

 

[Bouboumaster]

Perry has the more punchable face but it's close.

f*** this guy

 

[Bouboumaster]

Love Gallagher, but him and Marchand probably both have the two most punchable faces in the NHL

Just look at them.

GOAT punchable face tho:

Maxim Lapierre.