Where the Jays blew it is not so much with the home field but having to play Texas instead of the Yankees or Astros.
The Rangers are playing as well as anybody in the American League, have a legit ace to deal with and a lineup that can mash with the Jays. It's a toss up series IMO whereas the Jays would have been a heavy favorite against the Yanks or Astros.
Gibbons screwed up by playing the AAA lineup in the last game of the Baltimore series. There was no reason why he had to rest the entire lineup in that game.
I hear ya, but I don't think the reward for finally beating the Yankees in the regular season should be playing the Yankees in the first round. And Tanaka shuts the Jays down better than Gallardo does so I'm glad they don't have to line up against him in their first playoff game. If Tanaka managed to beat them again in game 1 then they would have to win 3/4 games with two of those being in NYC.
From ESPN Gallardo/Tanaka batter vs pitcher stats it has the Jays hitting .189 in 134 ab's vs Tanaka and .239 in 159 ab's vs Gallardo. That's a .050 adv to bat against Gallardo. Almost 2 extra hits/game.
IMO this works out well because they get to play someone besides NY in the first round, and if they have to play NY in the 2nd round then that means KC is out and the Jays have home field adv anyways.
There are 3 possible outcomes in these playoffs, #1 being the best and #3 being the worst:
Jays win the WS
Jays get knocked out by someone besides the Yankees
Jays get knocked out by the Yankees