Proposal: Artemi Panarin to SJS

[Dicdonya]

Ehhh 1st line could very well be stretching it. He needs to pot 30 before he gets put on the 1st line on my team.

Well maybe on your fictitious dream team you would expect that. However for CBJ who had zero 30g scorers, or the Blues who had 1 (not sure which team you are a fan of). They might be a little less stringent in their demands for a first line forward.

Getting a first full year 21 goal scorer, who started the year off playing on the third line. Is physical, and a good possession player. I don't believe too many, if any, teams would scoff so easily at the idea as you do.

Doesn't matter though really. I don't want Panarin for the cost he would likely demand, nor do I feel like risking him leaving the very next year after giving up that cost. CBJ can keep him, which I'm sure they are fine with.

 

[mikeyp24]

Well maybe on your fictitious dream team you would expect that. However for CBJ who had zero 30g scorers, or the Blues who had 1 (not sure which team you are a fan of). They might be a little less stringent in their demands for a first line forward.

Getting a first full year 21 goal scorer, who started the year off playing on the third line. Is physical, and a good possession player. I don't believe too many, if any, teams would scoff so easily at the idea as you do.

Doesn't matter though really. I don't want Panarin for the cost he would likely demand, nor do I feel like risking him leaving the very next year after giving up that cost. CBJ can keep him, which I'm sure they are fine with.

We have 2 of the players you are describing in PLD and Anderson. And our system stops players from putting up 30 although at least 2 to 3 of the guys could easily hit that on other teams. We are more of a defense 1st and counter with spead team which is why the PP was weak but we lead the league in goals after the TDL and into the 1st round. We have multiple people on the team who habe hit 30 its just more likely we have a load of 20 goal guys. We need game breaking and 0lay making not more guys like you are describing what you described is what we are known for and have an abundance of.

 

[SharksCyclops]

Of any trade partners, SJ seems like the least palatable one from CBJ's perspective

 

[Dicdonya]

We have 2 of the players you are describing in PLD and Anderson. And our system stops players from putting up 30 although at least 2 to 3 of the guys could easily hit that on other teams. We are more of a defense 1st and counter with spead team which is why the PP was weak but we lead the league in goals after the TDL and into the 1st round. We have multiple people on the team who habe hit 30 its just more likely we have a load of 20 goal guys. We need game breaking and 0lay making not more guys like you are describing what you described is what we are known for and have an abundance of.

Thats all good, I'm not saying no one on your team could score 30, just that they didn't. So if the guy I was quoting wouldn't take someone who's sub 30 goals on his first line, that excludes everyone, including Panarin from being a top line forward to him.

That's obviously stupid, and was really all my point was. Whether or not CLB would actually want Meier, or play him on their top line, I don't know, I don't know your team's needs well enough. If what you are saying is true, and you need less Meier types, than Labanc really would be our best prospect in terms of playmaking, and passing, minus the grit/possession. However hes less valuable than Meier, and highly doubtful to bring in someone like Panarin, which I still wouldn't want anyways, simply due to being a flight risk.

 

[Community]

**** just lock this then. People clearly don’t know Sharks players so that’s okay.

You asked for CBJ's #1 forward and offered back pieces that you think couldnt make their top 6 forwards. For a guy like Panarin, you need at least one great piece (liek Meier) and then add what is needed to it.

 

[JohnnyJacket13]

It would need to be Meier + another top prospect + 1st to even begin discussions

 

[Seatoo]

The offer isnt as bad as people are pretending but its not enough to get an elite player.

 

[Bizz]

that's an insane overpayment for Panarin.

CBJ doesn't have any leverage with him. He's an upcoming UFA who wants out. Lebanc Norris, and a 2nd should be more than enough.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Shows how much you know about reading comprehension.

I know the guy's name is Labanc, not Lebanc.

And the post I was repsonding to, if you actually bothered to read it without the spittle flying out of your mouth, was putting them on the 3rd line of their NEW team, which is what I said.

And I never said a thing about Meier, which you also didn't bother to read.

Tierney and Labanc are 3rd liners. Period.

I’m tempted to call Labanc a 2nd liner

 

[Hello Johnny]

that's an insane overpayment for Panarin.

CBJ doesn't have any leverage with him. He's an upcoming UFA who wants out. Lebanc Norris, and a 2nd should be more than enough.

Panarin literally wins games by himself. At a minimum, that second would need to be a 2019 1st with a conditional 1st in 2020 if Panarin re-signs. Even then, that's a lot of futures for Columbus to take when they are not looking for futures.

Meier + Norris + 2019 1st is fair for a player who puts the team on his back and wins games himself.

 

[Dr Quincy]

I’m tempted to call Labanc a 2nd liner

That's nice.

But again, the SJ fan I was responding to created the new lineups for both teams.

He put Panarin on SJS's 1st line, and had Tierney & Labanc on CBS's 3rd.

THAT was my point. You can get bogged down in the literal definitions of what a 2nd liner is or what a 3rd liner is, bu the point is this: He's offering 2 pieces he know are "depth" for a guy he knows is "core".

 

[Fistfullofbeer]

Do any CBJ fans know what AAV Panarin is wanting once he hits UFA?

 

[VoluntaryDom]

That's nice.

But again, the SJ fan I was responding to created the new lineups for both teams.

He put Panarin on SJS's 1st line, and had Tierney & Labanc on CBS's 3rd.

THAT was my point. You can get bogged down in the literal definitions of what a 2nd liner is or what a 3rd liner is, bu the point is this: He's offering 2 pieces he know are "depth" for a guy he knows is "core".

Ah. Yeah.

And yeah the OP is god-awful for Columbus. No question.

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

that's an insane overpayment for Panarin.

CBJ doesn't have any leverage with him. He's an upcoming UFA who wants out. Lebanc Norris, and a 2nd should be more than enough.

Disagree, other teams will be bidding... career ppg player.. lebanc norris and 2nd would be easily beat

 

[TomasHertlsRooster]

Panarin literally wins games by himself. At a minimum, that second would need to be a 2019 1st with a conditional 1st in 2020 if Panarin re-signs. Even then, that's a lot of futures for Columbus to take when they are not looking for futures.

Meier + Norris + 2019 1st is fair for a player who puts the team on his back and wins games himself.

I would be willing to do that for Panarin if he were willing to sign a $9M/8Y extension.

 

[Dumais]

Do any CBJ fans know what AAV Panarin is wanting once he hits UFA?

No, he isn't saying what he wants only declining offers.

I would be willing to do that for Panarin if he were willing to sign a $9M/8Y extension.

I'm pretty sure he wants double digit salary minimum.

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

I would be willing to do that for Panarin if he were willing to sign a $9M/8Y extension.

Panarin prob get 10 easily

 

[wintersej]

Panarin prob get 10 easily

I’d offer 8 @ 1 dollar more than Kane.

 

[TomasHertlsRooster]

Yeah, I would easily give Panarin $10M/8Y and probably wouldn’t have a problem with $11M either.

Would Columbus fans consider Meier+Norris+2020 1st for Panarin if he isn’t willing to re-sign?

 

[Viqsi]

Tierney and Labanc are both good players that I would very much like to see in union blue someday.

But in exchange for Panarin? **** right off with that bull****.