19. Buffalo Sabres
The broadcast: MSG Western New York carries Sabres games, with Rick Jeanneret and Dan Dunleavy on play-by-play and Rob Ray doing colour.
The results: Some of the deference Buffalo gets from national viewers can be chalked up to Jeanneret, who throughout an incredible career has managed to pull off something remarkable: although widely regarded as a Sabres partisan, he’s done such a good job historically that he’s forgiven for it.
“He’s a huge homer, but he does a great job being entertaining without making it all about him,” wrote one respondent from Detroit, who listed Buffalo’s broadcast as one of the best in the league.
Among local voters, Jeanneret’s legacy is secure. There was however a sense that after 15 years of short-term extensions — and a half-decade with his planned successor waiting in the wings on part-time duty — it was time for a change.
“The entire in-game experience needs to be refreshed,” said one of many such respondents.
Ray’s sense of humour earned him positive marks with some viewers, but the vast majority of respondents took issue with his commentary, with some picking on his overly pro-Sabres slant and others singling out an old-school approach to the game.
“He gets excited about fighting and literally nothing else,” said one.
The studio duo of Brian Duff and Martin Biron received nearly universal praise.
“Duffer and Marty are the perfect combo of analytics and first-hand experience,” wrote one respondent in a comment which was echoed throughout in-market ballots.
The bottom line: A decent overall rating masks a poor grade from locals and the pending difficulty of what happens post-Jeanneret.
Honesty thought this was Robs best year. And RJ was better than last year. The broadcast deserves a bottom half ranking for how many goals we missed while stats were being shown.The 2020 NHL broadcast rankings: The best and worst markets...
I think a ton of fans around the league will celebrate who ended up dead last in these rankings.
I think that is fair.
I would agree that Duff & Biron are top notch.
What happens with the cap will have a huge effect also. Less money will squeeze out marginal vets in favor of ELC, especially ones that don't have too many reachable bonuses attached.Prospects could have a much harder time making the jump to the NHL next season
That could be an interesting side effect of all of this.
Ranking the NHL's No. 1 overall picks of the 2010s
Maybe it's just me, but I'd put Mac ahead of Matthews.
I dont subscribe to the Althetic...just curious...where do Boston's, Buffalo's, and Pittsburgh's broadcasting teams rank ?The 2020 NHL broadcast rankings: The best and worst markets...
I think a ton of fans around the league will celebrate who ended up dead last in these rankings.
I think that is fair.
I would agree that Duff & Biron are top notch.
Dead last, 19th, second to lastI dont subscribe to the Althetic...just curious...where do Boston's, Buffalo's, and Pittsburgh's broadcasting teams rank ?
Wow...obviously I'm a big RJ fan but also a fan of Mike and Phil too...Mike has some classic calls...guess some people aren't into that and would rather have a robot call the gameDead last, 19th, second to last
Wow...obviously I'm a big RJ fan but also a fan of Mike and Phil too...Mike has some classic calls...guess some people aren't into that and would rather have a robot call the gameDead last, 19th, second to last
The 2020 NHL broadcast rankings: The best and worst markets...
I think a ton of fans around the league will celebrate who ended up dead last in these rankings.
I think that is fair.
I would agree that Duff & Biron are top notch.
Wow...obviously I'm a big RJ fan but also a fan of Mike and Phil too...Mike has some classic calls...guess some people aren't into that and would rather have a robot call the game