Timidity crept sneakily and silently into his game towards the end of his rookie season. It got its nasty hooks into him like a succubus and has been draining the effectiveness out of his game like blood ever since.
He hasn’t been able to shake it. It’s the monkey on his back that causes him to pass when he should shoot, miss wide open nets high and wide, double clutch on the puck, no look drop to nobody instead of driving the lane, and ceaselessly defer the puck ineffectually on the power play.
He’s shown in flashes he can play in the NHL at near-dominant levels. He absolutely has the skill to do so consistently. By all accounts he puts in the work to make it happen. But for whatever reason, when he hops over those boards, in real games, self-doubt seems to sink in.
I think that he also has some fear in his game. Physical fear. He’s soft. This often causes him to pass up on a direct play, in favor of a fancy play, so long as it takes him out of harm’s way. He might gain the zone with possession and speed, but the D will push him wide. Instead of going into the corner, or behind the net, and fighting to maintain possession, he’ll just chuck the puck into the slot. No-look pass to absolutely nobody. It makes it look like a great skill play. But I really suspect it was just a soft play. He wanted to look like he attempted a high skill play, but really he was just avoiding contact at all costs.
I don’t know what happened to him. I don’t know why he suddenly became such a complete and total wimp. I don’t remember any incident where he got crushed and he hasn’t been badly injured or anything. He had a pair when he came into the league. He played like a man. Then suddenly, he shelled up, and became a complete and total wussy.