Just my opinion but I think this is even worse than the Phillips re-signing and will cement the legacy of Bryan Murray as a failed GM.
I don't think so. It provides an experienced and competent veteran goaltender for the next 4 years while retaining a younger high potential goaltender who can apprentice on the job. Anderson can be a great mentor for Lehner.
Regarding Phillips, i think he is competent as a 5-6 defence man now and hopefully for the next two years. However, i would prefer to give the younger defence men like Wiercioch, Ceci, Cowen and Gryba the opportunity to get NHL game experience, as the Senators are not yet sufficiently skilled and ready to compete in the playoffs. If Phillips' play significantly deteriorates in the next two years, the Senators could sit him out and/or suggest he retire, or ask him to accept a trade to another team if he wants to continue playing. I am not sure if the Senators can buy him out. Does anyone know the buyout rules for someone at Phillips age and contract situation?