Andersen or Campbell

[Anthrax442]

I personally think that Andy's "slow starts" are more about the defense playing loosey goosey in the 1st 2 months rather than him being "off"

 

[Al14]

I personally think that Andy's "slow starts" are more about the defense playing loosey goosey in the 1st 2 months rather than him being "off"

Simple shots on net, that find a way through the goalie, cannot be blamed on the D playing loosey goosey. Andersen also has a penchant for allowing bad goals during the playoffs, and, not all playoffs start after an extended layoff like this season might!

 

[ottomaddox]

2019: Binnington - 0yrs playoffs experience
2018: Holtby - 5yrs
2017: Murray - 1yrs
2016: Murray - 0yrs
2015: Crawford - 4yrs
2014: Quick - 4yrs
2013: Crawford - 2yrs
2012: Quick - 2yrs
2011: Thomas - 2yrs
2010: Niemi - 0yrs
2009: Fleury - 2yrs
2008: Osgood - 11yrs
2007: Giguere - 2yrs
2006: Ward - 0yrs

Your numbers are completely fictional. If you want to present facts, then be accurate. Go back and look at JSG, Thomas, and Quick. They totally disprove your theory.

 

[zeke]

Your numbers are completely fictional. If you want to present facts, then be accurate. Go back and look at JSG, Thomas, and Quick. They totally disprove your theory.

Those numbers are all accurate.

Thomas, Quick, and Giguere all won the cup in their 3rd playoffs run.

 

[Morbo]

Andersen will get the start. But what happens after that is up to him.

 

[ottomaddox]

Those numbers are all accurate.

Thomas, Quick, and Giguere all won the cup in their 3rd playoffs run.

My bad. I thought you were talking about years/seasons in the NHL before winning a cup.

 

[zeke]

My bad. I thought you were talking about years/seasons in the NHL before winning a cup.

yeah I think the argument I was responding to was talking about Campbell having zero playoffs experience, so that's what I was going with.

 

[BlueBaron]

I'm still trying to understand how we had our name on a contract with Robin Lehner and we are asking Andy or Campbell ? It boggles the mind we let that guy pass through on a multi team deal that got us who ? Fmj

You know about the Cap?