Proposal: Ana/NYR/NJ/Edm

[Devilsrock17]

This is a proposal for fun doubt this would ever happen.
Rangers-Ryan Nugent Hopkins
Devils- Jacob Silfverberg
Ducks- Chris Kreider
Oilers- Damon Severson
Rangers get a much improved Center fit for a rebuild.
Devils get a secondary goal scorer.
Ducks add some speed and goals on the wing
Oilers add a defensemen which can jump into plays and be offensive.

Click to read more...

 

[Tad Mikowsky]

Boy, Oilers sure get the short end of this deal.

 

[Shootertooter]

The Rangers and Oilers making a swap of RNH for Kreider might be...... value wise, pretty good although there are obvious arguments for both fan bases to be against a move. My opinion is both the Devils and Ducks need to add, I would remove them from the equation.

 

[GAGLine]

Easy no from the Rangers. No need for RNH and certainly not at the expense of Kreider.

 

[A91]

Severson and Silfverberg are clearly inferior to RNH and Kreider

 

[hockeyguy1967]

Easy no from the Rangers. No need for RNH and certainly not at the expense of Kreider.

Yeah RNH is 2x the player Kreider is, hell no from Edmonton.

 

[Homesick]

The Oilers don't need a middle pairing defenseman at the cost of a 1LW/2C

 

[ManofSteel55]

Enter with best player, leave with worst. Seems about right for an Oilers proposal.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Oilers get absolutely obliterated here. Supposed ‘offensive’ defenceman had three more points than the much maligned Kris Russell

 

[Jumptheshark]

This is a proposal for fun doubt this would ever happen.
Rangers-Ryan Nugent Hopkins
Devils- Jacob Silfverberg
Ducks- Chris Kreider
Oilers- Damon Severson
Rangers get a much improved Center fit for a rebuild.
Devils get a secondary goal scorer.
Ducks add some speed and goals on the wing
Oilers add a defensemen which can jump into plays and be offensive.

Polite no from the oilers

 

[SML2]

Yeah RNH is 2x the player Kreider is, hell no from Edmonton.

There you have it. Both sides hate it. Chance of said players being dealt for each other just doubled.

 

[MMC]

Ducks do this in a heartbeat.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Terrible for Rangers. Looks very good for Ducks. Devils and Oilers kinda close call id imagine devils pass.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Enter with best player, leave with worst. Seems about right for an Oilers proposal.

Kreider says hi

 

[phillyb]

Rangers don't need centers, and it'll take more than RNH to take Kreider away from us, despite Zibanejad's injury (don't know where he stands today).

Edited to add: Below is a list of who's projected to be NYR's centers this year including who is listed as a W on Capfriendly, as well.
- Zib
- Hayes
- Spooner
- Namestnikov
- Andersson
- Chytil
- Holland
- Howden
- Nieves
- Fontaine
- Fogarty
- Vinnie Lettieri

The Rangers aren't exactly wanting for RNH in a year when they're not expected to contend...
Couple that with RNH's expiring deal, it's an easy NO from the Rangers.

 

[bernmeister]

Kreider says hi

This, AINEC.

 

[Nico Hischier]

This, AINEC.

Actually it’s very close bern. I think rnh is the best player in this deal krieder is second silfverberg is third and severson is fourth

Krieder and rnh are both borderline first liners so it’s very close and rnh can play the more important position center>winger

 

[Lays]

Enter with best player, leave with worst. Seems about right for an Oilers proposal.

I think you forgot the word “second” before “best”

 

[bernmeister]

Actually it’s very close bern. I think rnh is the best player in this deal krieder is second silfverberg is third and severson is fourth

Krieder and rnh are both borderline first liners so it’s very close and rnh can play the more important position center>winger

agree to disagree
RNH is a slightly more talented Stepan.
solid, but not spectacular
nothing more, nothing less

Kreider can actually dominate.
rnh is more skilled with his shot
but ck wins the other talent competitions
speed, strength, etc

 

[GAGLine]

Actually it’s very close bern. I think rnh is the best player in this deal krieder is second silfverberg is third and severson is fourth

Krieder and rnh are both borderline first liners so it’s very close and rnh can play the more important position center>winger

The value is close in a vacuum, but the Rangers have no need of a 1B center. Now, if you're talking about an elite center who can put up a ppg and play in all situations, that's a different story, but RNH is not that.

 

[lakai17]

brutal for Edmonton. RNH is decent, could center a few teams first line.

 

[Empoleon8771]

The Oilers don't need a middle pairing defenseman at the cost of a 1LW/2C

Yeah they only do that once, not twice

 

[thadd]

Be like the OP.
Come to trade proposals, where people make trade proposals for fun.
State that your trade proposal is for fun hopes that it allows self to avoid being flamed by netizens.
Post a proposal which includes 4 teams, which is against board policy, but also insure that at least 2 teams are getting screwed over.
Avoid HFboards for 1 month in hopes that nobody remembers this ever happened.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

As usual I find myself flabbergasted with Rangers fans love affair with a guy with a career high of 53 points and one 50+ point season. I don’t get it. He’s not as productive as Nuge, he doesn’t play as important a position as Nuge, he’s older than Nuge, but somehow he’s still surefire the best player in this deal (also ignoring that Edmonton doesn’t even end up with him in this deal, we get a guy that’s not even a clear upgrade on Matt Benning right now)

 

[McSuper]

Yeah RNH is 2x the player Kreider is, hell no from Edmonton.

Can you show me the math for your calculation . Hate when fans say this as it can not be proven . I am an Oiler fan who loves RNH and I would decline but my reason aren't made up . I want to see if the chemistry RNH and McDavid had at the end of last season is a flash in pan or the real deal .