Ok, now narrow that list down to guys who can do it every year for their career.
Over the last 5 seasons:
1. Erik Karlsson: 268GP,66G, 174A, 240P
2. PK Subban: 2684GP, 43G, 149A, 192P
3. Dustin Byfuglien: 262GP, 60P, 129A, 186P
4. Shea Weber: 289GP, 67G, 115A, 182P
5. Keith Yandle: 303GP, 35G, 147A, 182P
And you could argue Buff should be lower on the list since he played a bunch of games as a forward.
If you look at the last 8 seasons (Since Yandle has been in the league) he is 3rd overall behind Keith and Weber.