I don't know why all the speculation. By applying the rules, this is what is to happen.The Top 10 ELO is a 'guide' for the committee. The top 3 (1-3) and 5-7 are supposed be 'seeded' based on their 'ranking' then you can flip any team in the lower half (5-8) two spots to avoid intra-conf. games.
1 UNB 1978
2 UQTR 1819 <- if UQTR wins QC, they remain #2
3 UBC 1775
4 McG 1735
5 CAL 1734
6 TMU 1728
7 OTT 1699
8 MRU 1683
9 ALB 1632
10 BRK 1626
11 CON 1620
12 USK 1618
13 UdM 1610
Despite UdeM's low ELO, they will not be #8 (avoid #1 UNB)
If you treat UdeM as a 'runner-up', they would traditionally be in the 5-6 spot, if you go with ELO they would be 8th, but bumped to #7 to avoid UNB. So - they could be either 6-7 (CAL will be 5th)
As for "CAL will be 5th", there is only an ELO difference of 1 when compared to McG and it avoids an OUA/OUA in the 4/5 game (assuming McG wins bronze). On the topic of avoiding OUA/OUA, you don't want McG/BRK in the certain spots depending on who wins the QC
1. If UQTR wins QC
UNB, UQTR, UBC, TMU / CAL, McG/BRK, UdM, BRK/McG
2. If TMU wins QC
UNB, UBC, TMU, UQTR / CAL, UdM, BRK/McG, BRK/McG
Because it's fun to speculate. You have UdeM at 7 if UQTR wins and 6 if TMU wins?I don't know why all the speculation. By applying the rules, this is what is to happen.
- no intra-conference matchups;
- teams from 5-8 can shift 2 places.
I can add the brackets:
1 (UQTR wins OUA)
UNB v Brock/McGill loser
TMU v Calgary
UQTR v Moncton
UBC v Brock/McGill winner
2 (TMU wins OUA)
UNB v Brock/McGill loser
UQTR v Calgary
UBC v Brock/ McGill winner
TMU v Moncton
I don't know why all the speculation. By applying the rules, this is what is to happen.
- no intra-conference matchups;
- teams from 5-8 can shift 2 places.
I can add the brackets:
1 (UQTR wins OUA)
UNB v Brock/McGill loser
TMU v Calgary
UQTR v Moncton
UBC v Brock/McGill winner
2 (TMU wins OUA)
UNB v Brock/McGill loser
UQTR v Calgary
UBC v Brock/ McGill winner
TMU v Moncton
So much fun to speculate!Because it's fun to speculate. You have UdeM at 7 if UQTR wins and 6 if TMU wins?
You obviously know more about the OUA than me, but to me Ungar has looked considerably better than Shank. I always worry about a goalie standing on their head and stealing a game.So much fun to speculate!
To me, the unanswered question is in the event that TMU and McGill both win: Will the committee move U de M up the full two spots to #6, ahead of McGill (ranked waaaaay higher in ELO) to avoid an all-OUA first-round matchup? And does the fact that the OUA matchup would be intradivision change their opinion at all?
The USports playing regulations would suggest that they would, indeed, move U de M up to 6, which likely means they'd get an earful from McGill. But if they keep the Redbirds at 6, you're alienating your host team, and giving them a much tougher round 1 game.
I think it's fair to say the committee is rooting hard for UQTR.
By the way, Reds fans - you'll definitely play the OUA bronze loser. if I were you, I'd be cheering hard for McGill.
So much fun to speculate!
To me, the unanswered question is in the event that TMU and McGill both win: Will the committee move U de M up the full two spots to #6, ahead of McGill (ranked waaaaay higher in ELO) to avoid an all-OUA first-round matchup? And does the fact that the OUA matchup would be intradivision change their opinion at all?
The USports playing regulations would suggest that they would, indeed, move U de M up to 6, which likely means they'd get an earful from McGill. But if they keep the Redbirds at 6, you're alienating your host team, and giving them a much tougher round 1 game.
I think it's fair to say the committee is rooting hard for UQTR.
By the way, Reds fans - you'll definitely play the OUA bronze loser. if I were you, I'd be cheering hard for McGill.
There’s a lot of speculation because this isn’t a rule…the rule says the top two teams from a conference can’t play each other in the quarter-finals, but doesn’t mention anything about 1 or 2 facing 3 or 4.I don't know why all the speculation. By applying the rules, this is what is to happen.
- no intra-conference matchups;
Ungar is definitely the recipe for a 2-1 upset in a game where SOG are 45-17, so this is a fair point. McGill is a deeper and more skilled team, but Brock has the goaltending edge, for sure.You obviously know more about the OUA than me, but to me Ungar has looked considerably better than Shank. I always worry about a goalie standing on their head and stealing a game.
I’ve always preferred UNB play teams with stronger offense/weaker defense than the other way around. Teams that try to go end to end with UNB usually don’t fare well.
I hate to think that they would have to move most of the field around just to avoid an OUA first round matchup, especially with 4 OUA teams.So much fun to speculate!
To me, the unanswered question is in the event that TMU and McGill both win: Will the committee move U de M up the full two spots to #6, ahead of McGill (ranked waaaaay higher in ELO) to avoid an all-OUA first-round matchup? And does the fact that the OUA matchup would be intradivision change their opinion at all?
The USports playing regulations would suggest that they would, indeed, move U de M up to 6, which likely means they'd get an earful from McGill. But if they keep the Redbirds at 6, you're alienating your host team, and giving them a much tougher round 1 game.
I think it's fair to say the committee is rooting hard for UQTR.
By the way, Reds fans - you'll definitely play the OUA bronze loser. if I were you, I'd be cheering hard for McGill.
I agree, but a bit different not seeing UofA.Without doing any research I am
guessing this is the strongest field we have seen in the eight team era. Six teams with at least 21 regular season wins + TMU had 19.
This might be true, but I think it would be widely regarded that U de M (13th ELO) is a more favourable matchup for anyone than McGill (4th ELO). But then again, TMU beat McGill in their only matchup this season. So what do any of us know?!?I don't see any matchup being "favorable" to TMU.
I think the seeding are predictable after tonights games. #1 and #5 are solid.
Can I change my preference? A dominant second period has McGill comfortably ahead in the bronze medal game. A good goalie can only do so much when he is under a constant barrage of pressure and shots.Ungar is definitely the recipe for a 2-1 upset in a game where SOG are 45-17, so this is a fair point. McGill is a deeper and more skilled team, but Brock has the goaltending edge, for sure.
Yup. I find the announcer a bit annoying. Looking forward to game #2.With a comfy 4-1 lead, it's looking like Brock vs UNB. Thursday afternoon.
Too early to say what day UNB will be playing.With a comfy 4-1 lead, it's looking like Brock vs UNB. Thursday afternoon.
That's what I said, I think.....Too early to say what day UNB will be playing.
I believe TMU has already stated they are playing Thursday so if they win the OUA and go in #3 UNB will play Friday as they will be on opppsite sides of the bracket. If they lose tonight and go in #4 UNB/Brock will be Thursday afternoon.
Been a good game so far…fairly even despite the difference in shots, IMOQueen's Cup going to OT, tied at 2.
holiday inn on Carlton