Buyer beware
Rasmus Ristolainen: Much of what was said about Chiarot applies to Ristolainen. He’s big, mean and plays a lot of minutes which makes him attractive to those who don’t care that his teams rarely have the puck. He’s one of Philadelphia’s worst puck-movers and relies a lot on
Travis Sanheim to get the job done there — the primary reason his relative expected goals rate is above average for the first time in his career. On a weak Flyers team, that’s not saying a lot though as he’s still getting out-chanced and out-scored badly — with a lot of the damage coming on the defensive side of the puck.
A lot of folks had a “wait-and-see him outside of Buffalo” approach to his game, but what we saw was more of the same: a player who hurts his team when he’s out there. His impact isn’t as bad as Chiarot’s, but that’s only because Chiarot is having a nightmare season in Montreal which drags his value down, while Ristolainen’s season has been more business as usual. Over the last three seasons, Ristolainen’s teams have been 0.13 expected goals per 60 worse with him on the ice — and that’s on some very bad teams. Chiarot is at minus-0.17 which is close.
The big key for both: forget expected goals. Other teams earn 56-to-57 percent of actual goals at five-on-five over the last three years against either player. Over the last two, that’s closer to 60 percent. Why would any team go out of their way for that?
Joonas Korpisalo: In the bubble, Joonas Korpisalo made two lethal offences look like the
Arizona Coyotes and he’s been living off that reputation ever since. He had a .941 save percentage over nine games and saved six goals above expected.
Small sample sizes can inflate anyone’s standing and reputation, especially when the stakes are high, so let’s look at the bigger sample instead to find the truth. In 127 games before that playoff run, Korpisalo had a .908 save percentage and allowed 15.5 goals more than expected, about minus-0.12 per game. Bad, but not awful. Now imagine betting on those nine games as The Real Korpisalo and getting a sparkling .891 save percentage and minus-28 goals (!) allowed above expected over the next 51 games. Yuck.
Goalies are voodoo, but every shred of evidence suggests Korpisalo is not an upgrade over whoever your team’s guy is. There’s a chance, there’s always a chance, but it’s not a large one and not worth whatever high pick Columbus can somehow steal from another team for the privilege.