2005 prospect scout
Registered User
- Dec 10, 2019
- 18
- 3
Tough ask IMO, I haven't had a chance to watch half the perceived top prospects since Bantam. A lot changes in 9 months.Can someone list the top 20 forwards and the top 10 defenceman for this year draft?
Hearing that CSR may be coming out with their December list after all....this should be interesting!Can someone list the top 20 forwards and the top 10 defenceman for this year draft?
These lists are always way off. They change dramatically from Dec to May. It is always a good discussion point however.I've heard whispers about their list and as someone who as followed these guys for a couple years, what I've heard is pretty far from reality.
When will it be released?Hearing that CSR may be coming out with their December list after all....this should be interesting!
Typically early Dec, list 2 in early March and and the final list in early May.When will it be released?
Ok good but how can we see the two first list when it will be released?Typically early Dec, list 2 in early March and and the final list in early May.
I've heard whispers about their list and as someone who as followed these guys for a couple years, what I've heard is pretty far from reality.
NFLD's U18 league is dominated by 2004-2003's. Very few 05's making an impact, maybe they are just not getting the ice time or the opportunity to play with some vets. With Rotondi's departure, Strapp is the only one that I see as a top 4 rounder for forwards...Toole, Loveless will get some looks as well. French and Clay in nets are both looking good year to date. On D, Dawe would be leading the way...very few 05 D playing in this league.Who are the top end NL players this year in 2005 Birth year? Any 2004 making big improvements?
I agree 100%, its an unfortunate reality. If you look at the top NFLD players who have and are currently playing in the Q, USHL, BCHL....they all left home at such a young age.The NL kids are not seen on a regular basis like the NS, NB, and PEI kids. They only have Monctonian and Ice Jam and if they don’t play a great tournament or have a bad game that’s it, they are not seen anymore. Whereas there are always consistent viewings of the other Provinces. So if they have some bad games it doesn’t matter where they have eyes on them all the time. There are 03 and 04 kids that have lost out in NL. They were hoping for the Gatorade Challenge last year and the Atlantic’s for some extra viewings but obviously that did not happen. Hurt those kids for sure. And this year will be no different. No tournaments for any viewings for any of the 03, 04 and 05 kids. There are a bunch that are just as good and some better than kids that were drafted last year from the reviews I’ve been reading on some of last year’s draft picks. Some are struggling where they are young but I guess the potential to development was seen so they got drafted. There are kids in NL the same but weren’t drafted and given the chance. High school kids were drafted over kids that played AAA all their lives, was on all Provincial teams and are still playing AAA and are great players. Kids do develop at different stages but when your viewing are very limited and you are not a stand out superstar which most in Atlantic Canada are not you miss out. There are tons of good, consistent, hard working passionate players.
Keep working the teams will find the players and the players will find teams if there is a fit. Who are some players who have been missed? They could get drafted this yearThe NL kids are not seen on a regular basis like the NS, NB, and PEI kids. They only have Monctonian and Ice Jam and if they don’t play a great tournament or have a bad game that’s it, they are not seen anymore. Whereas there are always consistent viewings of the other Provinces. So if they have some bad games it doesn’t matter where they have eyes on them all the time. There are 03 and 04 kids that have lost out in NL. They were hoping for the Gatorade Challenge last year and the Atlantic’s for some extra viewings but obviously that did not happen. Hurt those kids for sure. And this year will be no different. No tournaments for any viewings for any of the 03, 04 and 05 kids. There are a bunch that are just as good and some better than kids that were drafted last year from the reviews I’ve been reading on some of last year’s draft picks. Some are struggling where they are young but I guess the potential to development was seen so they got drafted. There are kids in NL the same but weren’t drafted and given the chance. High school kids were drafted over kids that played AAA all their lives, was on all Provincial teams and are still playing AAA and are great players. Kids do develop at different stages but when your viewing are very limited and you are not a stand out superstar which most in Atlantic Canada are not you miss out. There are tons of good, consistent, hard working passionate players.
Do you have anything better to do lolVery bored so I’m Going to try and start a discussion. These are the 15 year olds I hope to watch in midget next year with these teams. Stated above that I hope to see...there are others that may be there yes.
Halifax
L.Welsh f
J. Plandowski f (away)
B.Shortall f
J.MacDonald d
C.Flemming g
Dartmouth
M.Green f
L.Foster f
W.Normandeau f
S. Bower d
B.Wamboldt d
C. Richardson g
ColeHarbour
D.Francis f
J.Todd f
M. Wagner f
B. Pilgrim f
L. McPhee f
R. Decoste g
South Shore
B. Coleman f
D. Rafuse f
O. Hatfield f
K. Harlow d
Valley
C. Burbidge f
N. Fowler f
A. Crocker f
C. Henderson f (away)
L. Orr (prep)
Pictou County
A. Tucker f
B. Wallace f
L. Crosby f
L. Lochead f
C. MacGillivary d
E. McNutt d (moved)
CB West
T. Peddle f
T. Grant f
R. Wood f
R. MacKinnon d
L. Stewart d
J. Milner g
Cape Breton
A. Christmas f
T. Lefresne d
J. Jobes d
There are 3 kids in N.S. that could play as under agers but I don’t think any will apply.
Q. Kennedy f
W. Shields f
I. Phillips d
Moncton
J. Gendron f
L. Patterson f
P. Collette f
R. Hopper f
P. Lounsbury f
W. Allen f (away)
D. MacKinnon d
JP Boudreau d
J. Martin d
S. Leblanc g
Northern
O. Arsenault f
N. Adams d
N. Ward d
Fredericton
B. Nadeau f
C. Morin f
D. Deschenes f
S. MacFarlane f
S. Mayo f
G. El-Tahhan f
M. Pelletier f (away)
A. Topilnyckyj d
S. Johnson d (away)
Saint John
N.Ryan f
J. Corscadden f
I. Dickie d
J. Flanagan g
Charlottetown
C. MacDonald f
C. Squires f
B. Arsenault f
B. Murphy f
J. MacDonald f
M. Senter f
H. Clements d
L. Coughlin d
N. Mossey d
Kensington
S. Bowness f
C. Alain f
P. Shea f
C . Arsenault d
K. Thompson g (away)
Players ifrom NL I would like to see:
M. Rotondi d
M. Strapp f
N. Crosbie f
T. Chafe f (away)
Moncton, Fredericton and Charlottetown get all them players and they would draw a lot of attention.
I read that M Pelletier is going to the PEI Mount. He stated it on his Twitter feed.[/QUOTE bit creepy
Did the Atlantic Provinces have any A's or B's?Saw the first list - some good players made the A and B ranking.
C and below have a ways to go to catch up
Still waiting on December 21/20 to come around. This was the time when all Minor Hockey + upper leagues start back up. Unless Heather Morrison changes her mind, although the announcement this morning from her was to open rinks up with restriction next week..Hey HKTalk, whats the status in PEI, back to the rinks soon?