GFS
Registered User
- Apr 12, 2010
- 3,003
- 265
Mackinnon
Kucherov wasn’t even a top contender for the Art Ross the year prior to his surgery, and he’s going to be really hungover based on how this summer has gone
We are voting for 3rd place right now. Not 1st. He’s obviously not the Art Ross favorite due to the Oilers duo, but after them Mackinnon is as likely as anyone.Kucherov wasn’t a contender but MacK was?
Kucherov pt finishes: 1,3,5,7
MacK pt finishes: 5,5,7,8
Also, MacK has never finished within 10pts of the Ross winner. He's never been a contender.
We are voting for 3rd place right now. Not 1st. He’s obviously not the Art Ross favorite due to the Oilers duo, but after them Mackinnon is as likely as anyone.
Last year Mackinnon came in 5th place, 2 points behind Pasta/Panarin who tied for 3rd with 95 points. Kucherov had 85.
Which is our most recent sample to analyze since Kucherov missed this past year.
He’s won 2 Stanley cups now, he’s going to be less motivated in the regular season since his team is a lock for the playoffs. And he is likely not training as hard this off season compared to the other guys in Art Ross contention, which is deserved based on his recent success.
Mackinnon is also 2 years younger as well.
However, in another poll (top players) Draisaitl is ranked 4th best player?
Why would Matthews be near the top of this list at all? Let alone a top 5 contender in points. He’s never been in Art Ross contention, and Marner has more frequently lead the leafs in points.Mack, Kuch, Matthews and Marner in some order for the next four
He was a top 5 scorer this year? lmaoWhy would Matthews be near the top of this list at all? He’s never been in Art Ross contention, and Marner has more frequently lead the leafs in points.
He’d surely be behind Panarin, Kane, and Marner at least
What's funny is that marner and matthews have had as high of a point finish mack has ever had(albeit he's been up there more regularly). The same argument he's using for mack could be used on the leafs players, they are younger too lol.He was a top 5 scorer this year? lmao
He was a top 5 scorer this year? lmao
kane played more. I submitted my list. You critiqued it not me. Matthews is younger than the others and already finished top 5. Not surprising he'd continue to improve. Somebody isn't happy hahaha. Marchand could very well be there too I just put me list.Rantanen and Kane had just as many points. Along being behind McDavid, Draisaitl, Marchand and Marner. You didn’t even mention Marchand.
Mackinnon had a better pace. And Kucherov didn’t even play last season.
And that’s just looking at last year, his case gets significantly worse when you go beyond that.
His point finishes in his career have been: 3 way tied for 5th, 9th, 42nd, 58th, 4 way tied for 20th
So I really don’t see how Matthews is a top 5 contender for the Art Ross.
Marner, Marchand, Huberdeau, Barkov, Crosby, Panarin, Kane, Pastarnak have all had 90+ point seasons and Matthews has never even scored over 80 in a season.
Just seems like another case of Matthews being forced into conversations he doesn’t really belong in. Aka all the painful to listen to “is Matthews the best player in the NHL” discussions that TSN loves to havekane played more. I submitted my list. You critiqued it not me. Matthews is younger than the others and already finished top 5. Not surprising he'd continue to improve. Somebody isn't happy hahaha. Marchand could very well be there too I just put me list.