I thought going through those exercises would make me like Rossi less and Perfetti more. That didn't happen.
I'm just looking at stats, reading scouting reports, watching highlight videos, and using my historical knowledge of entry drafts, though. Unlike
@tucknroll - I've seen these guys play in very few full games.
Rossi definitely seems behind the curve when adjusting for age, and I don't think taking a full year is fair. I like my method better because it doesn't mitigate experience factors as much. He's clearly a less productive player than these two if you age-adjust, even in a fair way.
However, he did have the single most productive D-2 year in the Swiss league ever. Ahead of guys like Meier, Hischier, Niederreiter, and Ehlers, etc. So that's also encouraging.
I just like some of what I've seen and read about Rossi. He's got an NHL ready game, and NHL ready build. Byfield is painfully lanky and plays too soft a game for his size (this could change). Perfetti is pretty soft too. Rossi on the other hand is a tank who doesn't lose many puck battles. Perfetti plays a super skilled, very nifty game. Byfield is a rush player who lives on transition. Rossi seems to be the most direct player, who spends the most amount of time in the high-danger areas. Byfield is a work in progress defensively, and Perfetti seems to be very poor in that regard (guilty of typical junior star cherry-picking, and cheating, etc). Rossi on the other hand is lauded as a three zone dynamo who's exception positionally and defensively. Then there is the fact that he's a true center and wins 60% of his draws already. Perfetti is likely to be a winger. Byfield is still working on some of the aspects of being a true center, it seems.
That said, it's all about projection. All I'm looking at is the last couple of years and the next couple of years. I like Rossi alot in that time range. But maybe he's lagging way behind beyond that. I guess that's what real scouts can see. It's hard to argue with a guy like Byfield who's arguably pretty close to Rossi now, but is 6'4 and skates like the wind.