Lets look at it this way, we have enough top 4 d in the system...With Rielly Gardiner Phaneuf Franson Fraser Gunner in the system plus Kostka and Holzer i dont really think we have room for another d man, a rental would be nice and all, but not at a hefty price. With Rielly and Gardiner eventually having to be in our top 4, whats the point of wasting assets for a guy who will be pushed out in the next year or two. If we can get a rental for cheap then go for it... But i think the partner for Phaneuf is already on our team developing into a solid consistent two way d man with top 4 skill and reliable hard working defense... He is right handed and his name is Cody Franson... I think Phaneuf-Franson could be a good pairing as they are both big guys who can use there body (Franson just started using his body this season) and they are both reliable enough in there own zone that they can cover for each other although they both make the occasional defensive mistakes.
Phaneuf-Franson
Fraser-Gardiner
Gunner-Rielly
Kostka/Holzer
But for this year run those same lines but put Liles where Rielly will be next year after we trade/buyout liles...