Proposal: 10 Trades that make sense

[93Ducks]

#1 omg. Just stoppppppppp

 

[Sojourn]

Rentals were worth more than... antropov was a bigger body who benefitted playing on a bad team with a superstar linemate.

I could mention patrick eaves got a second last year as a 21 goal scorer at deadline too.

Its very hard to find compables to maroon that got more than a second

Eaves was a conditional 2nd, that I believe turned into a late 1st. Anaheim needed to make the Conference Finals for that to happen.

 

[Nucks for the Cup]

That 1st trade is one of the worst I have ever seen. I would feel bad for getting that in return for Vanek. 2 former 1st rounders and a second for Vanek like cmon not even Jim Benning would offer that.



Actually he prob would but still horrible

 

[RussianSpy]

No from Dallas.

Huge overpayment.

 

[theghost1]

Link to justifications: The New Hockey Order

1.
Anaheim Receives:
Thomas Vanek
Vancouver Receives:
Jacob Larsson, Max Jones, 2018 3rd Round Pick

2.
St. Louis receives:
Max Pacioretty
Montreal receives:
Robby Fabbri, Klim Kostin, Jake Walman, 2019 Conditional 2nd*
*Becomes a 4th if Fabbri plays more than 25 games for Montreal in 2019

3.
Pittsburgh receives:
Derrick Brassard
Ottawa receives:
Ian Cole, 2018 1st round pick, Connor Sheary, Filip Gustavsson

4.
Nashville receives:
Rick Nash (salary retained)
New York receives:
2018 1st round pick, Frederic Allard, Pontus Aberg

5.
Tampa Bay receives:
Mike Green
Detroit receives:
Anthony Cirelli, Libor Hajek, 2nd round pick

6.
Tampa Bay receives:
J.G. Pageau
Ottawa receives:
Taylor Raddysh, Mitchell Stephens, 2019 4th round pick

7.
Toronto receives:
Johnny Oduya
Ottawa receives:
Josh Leivo, Martin Marincin

8.
Boston receives:
Patrick Maroon
Edmonton receives:
Zach Senyshyn, 2019 2nd round pick

9
New Jersey receives:
Jack Johnson
Columbus receives:
John Moore, Michael McLeod, 2019 3rd round pick

10.
Dallas receives:
Evander Kane
Buffalo receives:
2018 2nd round pick, Conditional 2019 1st round pick*, rights to Valeri Nichuskin, Denis Guryanov

Trade #2 AWFUL for Montreal.....please learn hockey u clown.

 

[Deam78]

Trade that make sense in a parallel world of nonsense making sense.

 

[Hockey Stick]

That is a ton for both Brassard and Pageau. Unreal work by Ottawa's gm if anything close to those happen

 

[Petes2424]

Link to justifications: The New Hockey Order

1.
Anaheim Receives:
Thomas Vanek
Vancouver Receives:
Jacob Larsson, Max Jones, 2018 3rd Round Pick

2.
St. Louis receives:
Max Pacioretty
Montreal receives:
Robby Fabbri, Klim Kostin, Jake Walman, 2019 Conditional 2nd*
*Becomes a 4th if Fabbri plays more than 25 games for Montreal in 2019

3.
Pittsburgh receives:
Derrick Brassard
Ottawa receives:
Ian Cole, 2018 1st round pick, Connor Sheary, Filip Gustavsson

4.
Nashville receives:
Rick Nash (salary retained)
New York receives:
2018 1st round pick, Frederic Allard, Pontus Aberg

5.
Tampa Bay receives:
Mike Green
Detroit receives:
Anthony Cirelli, Libor Hajek, 2nd round pick

6.
Tampa Bay receives:
J.G. Pageau
Ottawa receives:
Taylor Raddysh, Mitchell Stephens, 2019 4th round pick

7.
Toronto receives:
Johnny Oduya
Ottawa receives:
Josh Leivo, Martin Marincin

8.
Boston receives:
Patrick Maroon
Edmonton receives:
Zach Senyshyn, 2019 2nd round pick

9
New Jersey receives:
Jack Johnson
Columbus receives:
John Moore, Michael McLeod, 2019 3rd round pick

10.
Dallas receives:
Evander Kane
Buffalo receives:
2018 2nd round pick, Conditional 2019 1st round pick*, rights to Valeri Nichuskin, Denis Guryanov

You lost everyone on the first trade. The guy was traded last year at the deadline for a 3rd round pick..

 

[The Alien]

That vanek trade. Would do.

 

[BlueBaron]

Title needs to be changed to "10 crazy trades that don't make sense."