Proposal: 10 Trades that make sense

[Freaky Styley]

Link to justifications: The New Hockey Order

1.
Anaheim Receives:
Thomas Vanek
Vancouver Receives:
Jacob Larsson, Max Jones, 2018 3rd Round Pick

2.
St. Louis receives:
Max Pacioretty
Montreal receives:
Robby Fabbri, Klim Kostin, Jake Walman, 2019 Conditional 2nd*
*Becomes a 4th if Fabbri plays more than 25 games for Montreal in 2019

3.
Pittsburgh receives:
Derrick Brassard
Ottawa receives:
Ian Cole, 2018 1st round pick, Connor Sheary, Filip Gustavsson

4.
Nashville receives:
Rick Nash (salary retained)
New York receives:
2018 1st round pick, Frederic Allard, Pontus Aberg

5.
Tampa Bay receives:
Mike Green
Detroit receives:
Anthony Cirelli, Libor Hajek, 2nd round pick

6.
Tampa Bay receives:
J.G. Pageau
Ottawa receives:
Taylor Raddysh, Mitchell Stephens, 2019 4th round pick

7.
Toronto receives:
Johnny Oduya
Ottawa receives:
Josh Leivo, Martin Marincin

8.
Boston receives:
Patrick Maroon
Edmonton receives:
Zach Senyshyn, 2019 2nd round pick

9
New Jersey receives:
Jack Johnson
Columbus receives:
John Moore, Michael McLeod, 2019 3rd round pick

10.
Dallas receives:
Evander Kane
Buffalo receives:
2018 2nd round pick, Conditional 2019 1st round pick*, rights to Valeri Nichuskin, Denis Guryanov

Click to read more...

 

[BangarangxRufio]

#2 is a #2 for the

 

[AndreRoy]

Beyond horrendous for Tampa.

 

[bleedblue1223]

I have a feeling that not many of these make sense.

 

[ACC1224]

I don't mind the Leaf trade.

 

[Empoleon8771]

The Penguins aren't giving up Cole at this point, change Cole to Hunwick and you're probably pretty close.

 

[bsu]

1.
Anaheim Receives:
Thomas Vanek
Vancouver Receives:
Jacob Larsson, Max Jones, 2018 3rd Round Pick

2.
St. Louis receives:
Max Pacioretty
Montreal receives:
Robby Fabbri, Klim Kostin, Jake Walman, 2019 Conditional 2nd*
*Becomes a 4th if Fabbri plays more than 25 games for Montreal in 2019

3.
Pittsburgh receives:
Derrick Brassard
Ottawa receives:
Ian Cole, 2018 1st round pick, Connor Sheary, Filip Gustavsson

4.
Nashville receives:
Rick Nash (salary retained)
New York receives:
2018 1st round pick, Frederic Allard, Pontus Aberg

5.
Tampa Bay receives:
Mike Green
Detroit receives:
Anthony Cirelli, Libor Hajek, 2nd round pick

6.
Tampa Bay receives:
J.G. Pageau
Ottawa receives:
Taylor Raddysh, Mitchell Stephens, 2019 4th round pick

7.
Toronto receives:
Johnny Oduya
Ottawa receives:
Josh Leivo, Martin Marincin

8.
Boston receives:
Patrick Maroon
Edmonton receives:
Zach Senyshyn, 2019 2nd round pick

9
New Jersey receives:
Jack Johnson
Columbus receives:
John Moore, Michael McLeod, 2019 3rd round pick

10.
Dallas receives:
Evander Kane
Buffalo receives:
2018 2nd round pick, Conditional 2019 1st round pick*, rights to Valeri Nichuskin, Denis Guryanov

Reasoning can be found here. Flame away!

You've gotta be shitting me. Quite possibly worst trade I ever have seen on this forum.

 

[Starat327]

Is there a link to the 10 actual trades that make sense, or...?

 

[devilsfan35]

Highly doubt Columbus trades Johnson within the division.

 

[Skip2myBordyloo]

The trades make sense, the prices are too high for the rentals.

 

[King In The North]

Vanek four years ago might that. Tampa and Boston incredibly overpaying.

 

[SpeakingOfTheDevils]

NJ balks.

We're not giving up McLeod for a rental.

 

[Jay haller]

None of ythese are quality for quality! Pass

 

[Setec Astronomy]

NJ balks.

We're not giving up McLeod for a rental.

Much less a rental that sucks and who we don’t need. John Moore is also probably better than Jack Johnson at this point.

 

[bsu]

The trades make sense, the prices are too high for the rentals.

How does the first one make any sense at all for Anaheim? Giving up 2 great prospects and a 3rd for a player that would replace who in our top 9?

 

[AndreRoy]

The Tampa trades actually make far more sense if you take out all the prospects and leave only the picks. I can’t believe people actually post garbage like this.

 

[OVO16]

Honestly its not that bad. There's a couple that I feel like are an bit of an overpay for a rental

 

[DesertPenguin]

The Penguins aren't giving up Cole at this point, change Cole to Hunwick and you're probably pretty close.

Agreed, this is what I expect to see happen, with Hunwick instead of Cole. It's more than I'd like to give up but it's worth it to take a shot at history with a 3-peat.

 

[Harvey Birdman]

I second what EMP said, swap Cole for Hunwick and its close.

 

[HoseEmDown]

Tampa could send Raddysh + Hajek + Stephens + Cirelli + 2nd + 4th and be close on McDonagh or Karlsson not friggin Mike Green and J.G. Pageau.

 

[OCPenguin]

1.
Anaheim Receives:
Thomas Vanek
Vancouver Receives:
Jacob Larsson, Max Jones, 2018 3rd Round Pick

2.
St. Louis receives:
Max Pacioretty
Montreal receives:
Robby Fabbri, Klim Kostin, Jake Walman, 2019 Conditional 2nd*
*Becomes a 4th if Fabbri plays more than 25 games for Montreal in 2019

3.
Pittsburgh receives:
Derrick Brassard
Ottawa receives:
Ian Cole, 2018 1st round pick, Connor Sheary, Filip Gustavsson

4.
Nashville receives:
Rick Nash (salary retained)
New York receives:
2018 1st round pick, Frederic Allard, Pontus Aberg

5.
Tampa Bay receives:
Mike Green
Detroit receives:
Anthony Cirelli, Libor Hajek, 2nd round pick

6.
Tampa Bay receives:
J.G. Pageau
Ottawa receives:
Taylor Raddysh, Mitchell Stephens, 2019 4th round pick

7.
Toronto receives:
Johnny Oduya
Ottawa receives:
Josh Leivo, Martin Marincin

8.
Boston receives:
Patrick Maroon
Edmonton receives:
Zach Senyshyn, 2019 2nd round pick

9
New Jersey receives:
Jack Johnson
Columbus receives:
John Moore, Michael McLeod, 2019 3rd round pick

10.
Dallas receives:
Evander Kane
Buffalo receives:
2018 2nd round pick, Conditional 2019 1st round pick*, rights to Valeri Nichuskin, Denis Guryanov

Reasoning can be found here. Flame away!

Trade 3 makes no sense for Pittsburgh whatsoever. Sending four assets for Brassard is nuts. Sending Cole forces us to go out and send more assets for a good third D pair guy. How much is Ottawa retaining with this deal, 80%? LOL

 

[Setec Astronomy]

How does the first one make any sense at all for Anaheim? Giving up 2 great prospects and a 3rd for a player that would replace who in our top 9?

Vanek is going to end up being traded for a B prospect or second round pick from a contender. Most of the OP’s suggestions are pretty awful, no offense as I’m sure he’s a nice guy and all (or gal).

 

[AndreRoy]

I’m torn between the comedy value of seeing the supposed justifications for this garbage and not wanting to reward it with a click. Gonna go with the latter.

 

[Kent Nilsson]

The first two are really bad and then it gets progressively more reasonable somewhat.

 

[rent free]

i saw the first and knew this was gonna be a shitshow