Jack was still miles more effective than Tage even tho he sucked. Its not convoluted logic.. its just truth. Tage does not have the brain power, motor or ability to be on that line. The quicker the coach realizes this the better off the team will be. Tage playing at his best will be a drag on that line more often than not unless Jack and Taylor are in God mode.
Between the two, Jack was more productive, Tage was more effective.
Hall and Tage were the ones on the line that were making plays to keep pucks in or moving pucks. Yes, Tage, flubbed a few plays, but he actually stopped and made plays on the puck to keep pucks in, to help transition the puck, and interrupt plays. Jack skated by too many loose pucks, he held onto the puck too long where his options that were open, were no longer open because he waited too long.
Jack is the better player, but he didn't play to that level. Tage had the better game.