I figured I'd do a breakdown of our season from before Nylander signed, to after.
Oct-Dec
5v5 numbers:
51.4 cf% (13)
51.5 scoring chances% (11)
49 high danger% (18)
3.03 goals for/60 (6)
1.89 goals against/60 (5)
61.5 gf% (2)
1.048 PDO (1)
Powerplay:
15.16 goals for/60 (2)
89 scoring chances/60 (1, by a ton)
40 high danger chances/60 (1)
21.05 shooting% (3)
Penalty kill:
7.24 goals against/60 (12)
57.89 scoring chances against/60 (20)
32.5 high danger chances against/60 (29)
87.5 save% (9)
Overall:
51.26 cf% (14)
53 scoring chance% (10)
51.4 high danger% (13)
4.11 goals for/60 (1)
2.16 goals against/60 (3)
65.5 gf% (1)
13.25 shooting% (1)
93.83 sv% (2)
1.071 PDO (1)
Record: 20-8-0
Dec-Now
52.9 cf% (9)
54.7 scoring chance% (2)
53.7 high danger% (8)
2.6 goals for/60 (12)
2.28 goals against/60 (12)
53.23 GF% (11)
1.01 PDO (8)
Powerplay:
7.27 goals for/60 (14)
72.7 scoring chances/60 (1)
26.7 high danger chances/60 (6)
14 shooting percentage (15)
Penalty kill:
10.19 goals against/60 (26)
42.45 scoring chances against/60 (7)
12.74 high danger chances against/60 (1)
78.6 sv% (30)
Overall:
53 cf% (7)
55.6 scf% (1)
54.6 high danger% (5)
2.97 goals for/60 (14)
3.16 goals against/60 (21)
48.4 gf% (20)
9.43 shooting% (13)
89.98 sv% (22)
0.994 PDO (19)
Record: 24-17-5
Overall conclusions:
-Leafs started off the year with mediocre structure at 5v5, and got excellent goaltending and shooting luck
-Leafs now have excellent structure at 5v5, but are getting poor goaltending and mediocre shooting luck
-Leafs started out with terrible PK structure, and got bailed out by goaltending
-The PK structure is now excellent, and goaltending is sinking them
-The powerplay started off generating the most offense in the league, and they finished their chances
-The powerplay is still generating a lot, but the finishing has been mediocre at best
-The start of the year was unsustainable and mediocre play got bailed out by ridiculous PDO
-The Leafs are currently playing good hockey, but not getting much help from offense or goaltending
Overall, I think I am happy with where the Leafs are trending despite their record. It's better to bank on a structured team getting luck (especially with the shooters and goaltending we have) than to bank on our earlier lucky team suddenly playing with more structure.