Disclosure is required. It really depends on the form of disclosure though. All charities legally have to provide their statements if someone goes through the request process. That isn't great, but it is something. The last set of statements for ECF that I could find was for 2017 fiscal year.
It looks like the ECF gives a lot of money to that Inner City High School.
37% of their donations went to administration in 2016-17 which is on the high end. In comparison 18% of donations to the United Way of Northern Alberta goes to administration, 45% of YESS donations go to administration and 7% of donations to Edmonton's food ban goes to administration.
Since it is in the news 10% of WE charity donations go to administration, although they haven't released financial statements in 18 months.
All registered charities are required to submit an annual T-3010 (must be submitted within 6 months of the charities year-end) which breaks down revenue source and types of incurred expenses. This is all publicly available online via the CRA website (Google CRA List of Charities to find the link where you can search Canadian Registered Charities).
Just fact checking your info, I am curious how you got 45% for YESS admin expenses? From 2016-2019, YESS Admin + Management Costs fluctuated between 17-28% per the CRA website.
Regardless, as other posters have mentioned, each Charities situation is unique and without additional context it's hard to make judgments based off the numbers available.
Edit: to further the spread of information, as of 2019-06-30 the Edmonton Oilers Community Foundation reported Admin + Management Costs of 5.67%, fundraising costs of 55.48%, 24.73% being gifted to other registered charities, and 14.12% being used for its own charitable purpose.
Last edited: