Rumor: Trade Rumours and Proposals Thread: Las Vegas Exp Part 3: Who are they taking?

[Jimmi McJenkins]

Schemlko has a better deal and is signed longer. Good pick by Mcphee

Schlemko is an vastly overpaid #6/7 Defenseman, his deal isn't better, because he's just SUCH a step down from Dillon it's ridiculous.

 

[Seachd]

He's buds for example with the Islanders organization I believe since he worked there before. He's willing to give them a pass on the expansion draft.

But you think the Oilers are affected negatively by losing Reinhart? He's not the same type of player other teams are trying not to lose.

 

[Diamondillium]

What a terrible move by Chia. Should have paid to protect him. Trade just got worse. I don't have the blind faith like some of you when he makes moves like this

No, that's what MacT would have done. Paying to protect an asset you have no faith in just because you paid high is not a good GM move. It is a move of somebody who is afraid of 'losing' a trade.

He realized he lost the trade, and cut his losses because it makes no sense to pay even more to protect him.

 

[Raab]

He's not a bust just yet. That trade sure as hell is a bust though.

What stings for me is Montreal didn't even lose the player we thought we were going to lose AND we lost more depth at D. I'm an Oesterle fan as well, but he's a UFA, might not even be back.

Yep, makes that Davidsoin deal sting even more now. Especially with Sekera out.

 

[nhlisajoke]

if Reinhart is sent to the minors doesnt he need waivers?

 

[McDNicks17]

Schlemko is an vastly overpaid #6/7 Defenseman, his deal isn't better, because he's just SUCH a step down from Dillon it's ridiculous.

Huh?

I think you have them mixed up.

 

[Oilersfan93]

hopefully losing reinhart will light up a fire under chiapete's ass, and he gets to work and gets us a better deal on the jordan "gap-teeth" eberle.

 

[oilers4life5]

and here comes the Anti Chiarelli crowd just as expected.

I have said this for months. Get a clue.

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

just a brutal trade by Chia....so many wasted assets on a bottom-pairing d-man at best

hope he never listen to Bob Green again with regards to trades

 

[IAGTTAYM]

 

[Jimmi McJenkins]

Huh?

I think you have them mixed up.

David Schlemko is garbage. He could barely be put on the ice as the Oilers/Sharks series went along because he was being eaten alive.

 

[CupofOil]

Sucks they are taking other teams junk (Emelin, Englland.. WTF) while we lose a good player.

But the Oilers lost Reinhart.

No real reason to watch the awards show tonight now.

 

[McAsuno]

I have said this for months. Get a clue.

Yeah, he made one bad deal. Pretty sure his deals in general have good outweighing the bad, but keep on the "Chiarelli sucks" narrative. I guess you prefer MacT and Tambo.

 

[oilers4life5]

No, that's what MacT would have done. Paying to protect an asset you have no faith in just because you paid high is not a good GM move. It is a move of somebody who is afraid of 'losing' a trade.

He realized he lost the trade, and cut his losses because it makes no sense to pay even more to protect him.

We are just so flush with cheap NHL ready d men we can afford to lose them for nothing. I don't think so. Griff was progressing well. Would have been an ideal #7

 

[McDNicks17]

Damn it! We just lost a top 4 dman for nothing. I know Reinhart didn't play with the big team last year, but I can guarantee he's going to surprise some people in Vegas.

The surprise would be him playing NHL games.

 

[Canovin]

GM McPhee: "For my first day at work I'm going to be taking a lot of busts"

 

[rickysusedsht]

You're suggesting Reinhart isn't a scrub? He's tweener who needs waivers starting next season. I give it better than 50% odds we'd be able to grab him come the start of next season off waivers.

yes he isnt great but after what was given up and also being a D .just feel like someone stole my car after i over paid for it and still making payments on it

 

[Weitz]

Good thing Chia spent a 1st and 2nd on that terrible defencman.

 

[oilers4life5]

Yeah, he made one bad deal. Pretty sure his deals in general have good outweighing the bad, but keep on the "Chiarelli sucks" narrative. I guess you prefer MacT and Tambo.

Did I say that he sucks? I must have missed that part.

 

[Beerfish]

Yeah, he made one bad deal. Pretty sure his deals in general have good outweighing the bad, but keep on the "Chiarelli sucks" narrative. I guess you prefer MacT and Tambo.

He listened to mact and green on that one (both still employed by the team) so he deserves every bit of flack he is going to get. It was an AWFUL AWFUL deal from day one.

 

[McDrai]

How the **** does Vegas take Engelland without compensation from Calgary? 35 years old, UFA, and a career high of 17 points. Mcphee is dumb as hell

 

[CupofOil]

nevermind

 

[Canovin]

yes he isnt great but after what was given up and also being a D .just feel like someone stole my car after i over paid for it and still making payments on it

And never had a chance to test drive it

 

[Seachd]

We are just so flush with cheap NHL ready d men we can afford to lose them for nothing. I don't think so. Griff was progressing well. Would have been an ideal #7

It's an expansion draft. You can't really lose anything less than a #7 defenseman. They're lucky that's all they lost.

 

[Smartguy]

But the Oilers lost Reinhart.

Indeed the only reason Reinhart is a blow is because we traded a fortune for him not that long ago, a stain on chia's record, but Talbot was a home run so meh the good with the bad