That is why are opinions are so different. i personally do not see us winning a cup or going to the finals while we have Anderson not because he is bad but because i think it will take longer for us to get good enough.
i think in 3-5 years is when we start really competing for the cup if all goes well. Anderson will not be our goalie O'Connor, Hammond, or someone else will (someone good enough) Meanwhile we have a core group of Turris, Ryan, Stone, Karlsson, Ceci and 2 of Z-Bad, Lazar, White, Chabot, Paul, Prince, Puempel, Hoffman, Methot, 2016 1st (or other picks/prospects)
that group will be mostly in their primes and have enough experience and enough good supporting players to compete.
Unfortunately i don't view our team as team that will be able to win the cup year to year like Chicago or LA has but i think we will be able to get be a top team for a good enough amount of time that we can sneak a cup win in.