Exactly. McPhee’s drafting in similar positions yielded far better players than Maclellan’s. Carlson, Kuzy, Orlov, Bura, Stephenson, Eakin, Sanford, Djoos, Boyd, Grubauer, MJ, Holtby, Varlamov, Neuvirth, and Perreault were all players drafted in positions similar to those Maclellan’s staff had. Sure the jury is out on some of Maclellan’s picks but by and large it’s not looking good. Fever and possibly Iorio could be the only diamonds in the rough he’s drafted. I had some high hopes for Protas but the more I watch him the lower his ceiling becomes in my mind.
McPhee has had his warts as well but Maclellan’s poor drafting has not helped our roster vis a vis the salary cap. And yes I understand Mahoney plays a role but Mahoney doesn’t draft in a vacuum, of course Maclellan’s input and perceived needs are factors.